Zhou Chuan, Chan Heang-Ping, Patel Smita, Cascade Philip N, Sahiner Berkman, Hadjiiski Lubomir M, Kazerooni Ella A
Department of Radiology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, CGC B2103, 1500 E. Medical Center Drive, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
Acad Radiol. 2005 Jun;12(6):782-92. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2005.01.014.
We sought to develop a computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) system for assisting radiologists in the detection of pulmonary embolism (PE) on computed tomography pulmonary angiographic (CTPA) images.
An adaptive three-dimensional (3D) voxel clustering method was developed based on expectation-maximization (EM) analysis to extract vessels from their surrounding tissues. Using a connected component analysis, the vessel tree was reconstructed by tracking the vessel and its branches in 3D space. The tracked vessels were prescreened for suspicious PE areas using a second EM analysis. A rule-based false-positive (FP) reduction method was designed to detect true PE based on the features of PE and vessels. In this preliminary study, 14 patients with positive CTPA for PE were studied. CT scans were performed at 1.25-mm collimation using a GE LightSpeed CT scanner; eight of these patients also had extensive lung parenchymal or pleural disease. One hundred sixty-three emboli were identified by two experienced thoracic radiologists. The emboli identified by the radiologists were used as the "gold standard." For each embolus, the percent diameter occlusion (clot) and conspicuity of embolus (rating of 1 to 5, with 5 being the most conspicuous) were visually estimated. One hundred one emboli were identified in the six patients without lung diseases; 57 were proximal to the subsegmental and 44 were subsegmental. For the eight patients with lung diseases, 62 emboli were identified, of which 37 were proximal to the subsegmental and 25 were subsegmental. A computer-detected volume was counted as true-positive when it overlapped with an embolus volume identified by the radiologists.
In the cases without lung diseases, if the PE had a conspicuity of >2 and only partially (20%-80%) occluded the vessel, our method detected 92.0% of proximal emboli and 77.8% of subsegmental emboli, with an average of 18.3 FPs/case. In the cases containing extensive lung disease, 66.7% and 40.0% of the PEs were detected with an average of 11.4 FPs/case under the same conditions. For the 14 PE cases, 13 of them were diagnosed as positive PE cases (case sensitivity was 92.9%).
This preliminary study indicates that our automated method is a promising approach to CAD of PE on CTPA. Further study is under way to collect a larger data set and to improve the detection accuracy for PE, especially those with <20% or >80% occlusion, and for very subtle PE. A fully developed CAD system is expected to provide a useful aid for PE detection on CTPA.
我们试图开发一种计算机辅助诊断(CAD)系统,以协助放射科医生在计算机断层扫描肺动脉造影(CTPA)图像上检测肺栓塞(PE)。
基于期望最大化(EM)分析开发了一种自适应三维(3D)体素聚类方法,以从周围组织中提取血管。使用连通分量分析,通过在三维空间中跟踪血管及其分支来重建血管树。使用第二次EM分析对跟踪到的血管进行可疑PE区域的预筛选。设计了一种基于规则的假阳性(FP)减少方法,以根据PE和血管的特征检测真正的PE。在这项初步研究中,对14例CTPA检查显示PE阳性的患者进行了研究。使用GE LightSpeed CT扫描仪以1.25毫米的准直进行CT扫描;其中8例患者还患有广泛的肺实质或胸膜疾病。两名经验丰富的胸科放射科医生共识别出163个栓子。放射科医生识别出的栓子被用作“金标准”。对于每个栓子,通过视觉估计栓子的直径阻塞百分比(血栓)和栓子的明显程度(评分为1至5,5为最明显)。在6例无肺部疾病的患者中识别出101个栓子;其中57个位于亚段近端,44个为亚段栓子。对于8例患有肺部疾病的患者,识别出62个栓子,其中37个位于亚段近端,25个为亚段栓子。当计算机检测到的体积与放射科医生识别出的栓子体积重叠时,计为真阳性。
在无肺部疾病的病例中,如果PE的明显程度>2且仅部分(20%-80%)阻塞血管,我们的方法检测到92.0%的近端栓子和77.8%的亚段栓子,平均每个病例有18.3个假阳性。在包含广泛肺部疾病的病例中,在相同条件下检测到66.7%和40.0%的PE,平均每个病例有11.4个假阳性。对于14例PE病例,其中13例被诊断为PE阳性病例(病例敏感性为92.9%)。
这项初步研究表明,我们的自动化方法是CTPA上PE的CAD的一种有前途的方法。正在进行进一步的研究,以收集更大的数据集并提高PE的检测准确性,特别是那些阻塞<20%或>80%的PE以及非常微小的PE。一个完全开发的CAD系统有望为CTPA上的PE检测提供有用的辅助。