Munson Benjamin, Edwards Jan, Beckman Mary E
Department of Speech-Language-Hearing Sciences, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55455, USA.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2005 Feb;48(1):61-78. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2005/006).
A growing body of research has documented effects of phonotactic probability on young children's nonword repetition. This study extends this research in 2 ways. First, it compares nonword repetitions by 40 young children with phonological disorders with those by 40 same-age peers with typical phonological development on a nonword repetition task in which the frequency of embedded diphone sequences was varied. Second, it examines the relationship between the frequency effect in the nonword repetition task and other measures of linguistic ability in these children. Children in both groups repeated low-frequency sequences less accurately than high-frequency sequences. The children with phonological disorders were less accurate overall but showed no larger disadvantage for the low-frequency sequences than their age peers. Across the group, the size of the frequency effect was correlated with vocabulary size, but it was independent of measures of speech perception and articulatory ability. These results support the hypothesis that the production difficulty associated with low-frequency sequences is related primarily to vocabulary growth rather than to developments in articulatory or perceptual ability. By contrast, production problems experienced by children with phonological disorders do not appear to result from difficulties in making abstractions over known lexical items. Instead, they may be associated with difficulties in building representations in the primary sensory and motor domains.
越来越多的研究记录了音位概率对幼儿非词重复的影响。本研究从两个方面扩展了这项研究。首先,在一个非词重复任务中,将40名患有语音障碍的幼儿的非词重复与40名同龄且语音发育正常的同伴的非词重复进行比较,该任务中嵌入的双音素序列的频率是变化的。其次,研究非词重复任务中的频率效应与这些儿童的其他语言能力测量指标之间的关系。两组儿童对低频序列的重复准确性均低于高频序列。患有语音障碍的儿童总体上准确性较低,但在低频序列上并不比同龄人有更大的劣势。在整个群体中,频率效应的大小与词汇量相关,但与语音感知和发音能力的测量指标无关。这些结果支持了这样一种假设,即与低频序列相关的生成困难主要与词汇增长有关,而不是与发音或感知能力的发展有关。相比之下,患有语音障碍的儿童所经历的生成问题似乎并非源于对已知词汇项进行抽象的困难。相反,它们可能与在主要感觉和运动领域构建表征的困难有关。