Burgess Ian F, Brown Christine M, Lee Peter N
Insect Research and Development, Shepreth, Royston SG8 6QZ.
BMJ. 2005 Jun 18;330(7505):1423. doi: 10.1136/bmj.38497.506481.8F. Epub 2005 Jun 10.
To evaluate the efficacy and safety of 4% dimeticone lotion for treatment of head louse infestation.
Randomised controlled equivalence trial.
Community, with home visits.
214 young people aged 4 to 18 years and 39 adults with active head louse infestation.
Two applications seven days apart of either 4.0% dimeticone lotion, applied for eight hours or overnight, or 0.5% phenothrin liquid, applied for 12 hours or overnight.
Cure of infestation (no evidence of head lice after second treatment) or reinfestation after cure.
Cure or reinfestation after cure occurred in 89 of 127 (70%) participants treated with dimeticone and 94 of 125 (75%) treated with phenothrin (difference -5%, 95% confidence interval -16% to 6%). Per protocol analysis showed that 84 of 121 (69%) participants were cured with dimeticone and 90 of 116 (78%) were cured with phenothrin. Irritant reactions occurred significantly less with dimeticone (3/127, 2%) than with phenothrin (11/125, 9%; difference -6%, -12% to -1%). Per protocol this was 3 of 121 (3%) participants treated with dimeticone and 10 of 116 (9%) treated with phenothrin (difference -6%, -12% to -0.3%).
Dimeticone lotion cures head louse infestation. Dimeticone seems less irritant than existing treatments and has a physical action on lice that should not be affected by resistance to neurotoxic insecticides.
评估4%二甲基硅油洗剂治疗头虱感染的疗效和安全性。
随机对照等效性试验。
社区,进行家访。
214名4至18岁的年轻人和39名患有活动性头虱感染的成年人。
间隔7天两次涂抹4.0%二甲基硅油洗剂,涂抹8小时或过夜,或0.5%氯菊酯液,涂抹12小时或过夜。
感染治愈(第二次治疗后无头虱迹象)或治愈后再次感染。
127名接受二甲基硅油治疗的参与者中有89名(70%)治愈或治愈后再次感染,125名接受氯菊酯治疗的参与者中有94名(75%)治愈或治愈后再次感染(差异-5%,95%置信区间-16%至6%)。符合方案分析显示,121名接受二甲基硅油治疗的参与者中有84名(69%)治愈,116名接受氯菊酯治疗的参与者中有90名(78%)治愈。二甲基硅油引起的刺激性反应明显少于氯菊酯(3/127,2%)比氯菊酯(11/125,9%;差异-6%,-12%至-1%)。符合方案分析显示,121名接受二甲基硅油治疗的参与者中有3名(3%)出现反应,116名接受氯菊酯治疗的参与者中有10名(9%)出现反应(差异-6%,-12%至-0.3%)。
二甲基硅油洗剂可治愈头虱感染。二甲基硅油似乎比现有治疗方法刺激性更小,对虱子有物理作用,不应受对神经毒性杀虫剂耐药性的影响。