Crouch R, Whitewick R, Clancy M, Wright P, Thomas P
Emergency Department, Southampton General Hospital, Southampton, Hampshire, SO16 6YD, UK.
Emerg Med J. 2006 Feb;23(2):114-8. doi: 10.1136/emj.2004.022145.
To describe the epidemiology, process of care, and outcomes at 4-6 weeks after injury among patients with whiplash associated disorder attending a UK emergency department.
All patients presenting during the study period with neck pain following a road traffic accident who met the inclusion criteria were assessed. Patients were followed up with a telephone interview at 4-6 weeks after attendance using the Neck Disability Index (NDI). The patient's general practitioner (GP) was contacted post attendance to ascertain subsequent healthcare use.
A total of 200 patients were recruited to the study, of which 30 were lost to follow up. Four variables, midline tenderness (p = 0.008; 95% CI 0.9 to 6.1), x ray request (p = 0.004; 0.9 to 6.1), wearing a seat belt (p = 0.038; 0.2 to 6.2), and having seen their GP post injury (p = 0.001; CI -10.5 to 6.6), were found to be associated with a higher NDI score at follow up. Significant correlation was identified with a high pain score and an increasing age of patient and high NDI scores. No correlation was found between the impact speed, speed of vehicle struck, or time since incident with the NDI. Two thirds of patients had some disability at 4-6 weeks after injury; 91 patients (54.5%) saw their GP in the intervening period between attending the department and telephone follow up, and 87/170 patients had no idea about their prognosis.
This study identifies that there is significant disability associated with whiplash associated disorder. Clear prognostic information would be a useful development.
描述在英国急诊科就诊的挥鞭样损伤相关疾病患者受伤后4至6周的流行病学、治疗过程及预后情况。
对研究期间因道路交通事故后出现颈部疼痛且符合纳入标准的所有患者进行评估。患者在就诊后4至6周接受电话随访,使用颈部功能障碍指数(NDI)进行评估。就诊后联系患者的全科医生(GP)以确定后续的医疗保健使用情况。
共招募了200名患者参与研究,其中30名失访。发现四个变量,即中线压痛(p = 0.008;95%可信区间0.9至6.1)、X光检查申请(p = 0.004;0.9至6.1)、系安全带(p = 0.038;0.2至6.2)以及受伤后看过全科医生(p = 0.001;可信区间-10.5至6.6)与随访时较高的NDI评分相关。发现疼痛评分高、患者年龄增加与NDI评分高之间存在显著相关性。未发现撞击速度、被撞车辆速度或事故发生后的时间与NDI之间存在相关性。三分之二的患者在受伤后4至6周存在一定程度的功能障碍;91名患者(54.5%)在就诊至电话随访期间看过全科医生,170名患者中有87名对其预后一无所知。
本研究表明,挥鞭样损伤相关疾病会导致显著的功能障碍。提供明确的预后信息将是一项有益的进展。