Christian Allison H, Mills Thomas, Simpson Susan Lee, Mosca Lori
Columbia University, College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2006 Mar;21(3):231-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1525-1497.2006.00331.x.
Quality of cardiovascular disease (CVD) preventive care is suboptimal. Recent data correlated increasing years in practice for physicians with lower-quality health care.
The purpose of this study was to assess physician awareness/adherence to national blood pressure, cholesterol, and CVD prevention guidelines for women according to physician/practice characteristics.
Standardized online survey and experimental case studies were administered to 500 randomly selected U.S. physicians. Multivariable regression models tested physician age, gender, specialty, and practice type as independent predictors of guideline awareness/adherence.
Compared with older physicians (50+ years), younger physicians (<50 years) reported a lower level of awareness of cholesterol guidelines (P=.04) and lower incorporation of women's guidelines (P=.02). Yet, older physicians were less likely to recommend weight management for high-risk cases (P=.03) and less confident in helping patients manage weight (P=.045) than younger physicians. Older physicians were also less likely to identify a low-density lipoprotein<100 mg/dL as optimal versus younger physicians (P=.01), as were solo versus nonsolo practitioners (P=.02). Solo practitioners were less aware of cholesterol guidelines (P=.04) and were more likely to prescribe aspirin for low-risk female patients than nonsolo practitioners (P<.01). Solo practitioners rated their clinical judgment as more effective than guidelines in improving patient health outcomes (P<.01) and more frequently rated the patient as the greatest barrier to CVD prevention versus nonsolo practitioners (P<.01).
Though guideline awareness is high, efforts to promote their utilization are needed and may improve quality outcomes. Targeted education and support for CVD prevention may be helpful to older and solo physicians.
心血管疾病(CVD)预防护理的质量并不理想。最近的数据表明,医生从业年限增加与医疗质量下降相关。
本研究旨在根据医生/执业特征评估医生对国家女性血压、胆固醇和CVD预防指南的知晓度/依从性。
对500名随机选择的美国医生进行标准化在线调查和实验性案例研究。多变量回归模型测试医生年龄、性别、专业和执业类型作为指南知晓度/依从性的独立预测因素。
与年长医生(50岁以上)相比,年轻医生(<50岁)报告的胆固醇指南知晓水平较低(P = 0.04),女性指南的纳入率也较低(P = 0.02)。然而,与年轻医生相比,年长医生在高危病例中推荐体重管理的可能性较小(P = 0.03),并且在帮助患者管理体重方面的信心较低(P = 0.045)。与年轻医生相比,年长医生也不太可能将低密度脂蛋白<100 mg/dL视为最佳水平(P = 0.01),个体执业医生与非个体执业医生相比也是如此(P = 0.02)。个体执业医生对胆固醇指南的知晓度较低(P = 0.04),并且比非个体执业医生更有可能为低风险女性患者开阿司匹林(P < 0.01)。个体执业医生认为他们的临床判断在改善患者健康结果方面比指南更有效(P < 0.01),并且与非个体执业医生相比,他们更频繁地将患者视为CVD预防的最大障碍(P < 0.01)。
尽管指南知晓度较高,但仍需要努力促进其应用,这可能会改善质量结果。针对CVD预防的有针对性的教育和支持可能对年长和个体执业医生有所帮助。