Peterson Rachael C, Wolffsohn James S, Nick Joachim, Winterton Lynn, Lally John
Life and Health Sciences, Aston University, Aston Triangle, Birmingham, UK.
Cont Lens Anterior Eye. 2006 Jul;29(3):127-34. doi: 10.1016/j.clae.2006.03.004. Epub 2006 May 9.
Polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) is a successful tear film stabiliser and is widely used in comfort drops and some soft contact lens materials. A PVA-containing lens, nelfilcon A has been modified to include additional (non-functional) PVA in order to provide improved comfort. This study aims to examine the clinical performance of this nelfilcon A lens with AquaRelease (AquaRelease).
Two contralateral, investigator masked, open label, subjective and objective evaluations were conducted. The first examined the effect of adding increased molecular weight PVA to nelfilcon A (n=5), and the second compared this AquaRelease lens to ocufilcon B (n=34). The principal measures were non-invasive break-up time (NIBUT) and subjective comfort, which were assessed at the beginning and end of a week of daily wear, and three times throughout 1 day at 8, 12 and 16 h.
All subjects successfully completed the daily wearing schedule of 16h. On initial insertion, subjective comfort and NIBUT improved for AquaRelease than original nelfilcon A lenses (p<0.05). Initial comfort was better for AquaRelease compared to ocufilcon B lenses (p=0.01); however, NIBUT was not statistically different (11.7+/-15.6s versus 8.4+/-6.8s; p=0.26). Subjective comfort decreased with time (p<0.001), but there was no significant difference between AquaRelease and ocufilcon B lenses (p=0.16). NIBUT was not significantly affected by time (p=0.56) or between lenses (p=0.33). At the end of a weeks' wear, subjective initial, end-of-day, overall comfort and vision were rated significantly better with AquaRelease than ocufilcon B (p<0.01).
Release of additional non-functionalised PVA from the nelfilcon A lenses appears to enhance comfortable contact lens wear.
聚乙烯醇(PVA)是一种成功的泪膜稳定剂,广泛应用于润眼液和一些软性隐形眼镜材料中。一种含PVA的镜片,奈非康A已进行改良,加入了额外的(无功能的)PVA以提高舒适度。本研究旨在检验这种含AquaRelease的奈非康A镜片(AquaRelease)的临床性能。
进行了两项对侧、研究者设盲、开放标签的主观和客观评估。第一项评估了向奈非康A中添加高分子量PVA的效果(n = 5),第二项将这种AquaRelease镜片与欧舒适B(ocufilcon B)进行了比较(n = 34)。主要测量指标为非侵入性泪膜破裂时间(NIBUT)和主观舒适度,在每日佩戴一周的开始和结束时进行评估,并在一天中的8、12和16时这三个时间点进行评估。
所有受试者均成功完成了16小时的每日佩戴计划。初次佩戴时,AquaRelease的主观舒适度和NIBUT比原始的奈非康A镜片有所改善(p < 0.05)。与欧舒适B镜片相比,AquaRelease的初始舒适度更好(p = 0.01);然而,NIBUT在统计学上无差异(11.7±15.6秒对8.4±6.8秒;p = 0.26)。主观舒适度随时间下降(p < 0.001),但AquaRelease和欧舒适B镜片之间无显著差异(p = 0.16)。NIBUT不受时间影响(p = 0.56),镜片之间也无差异(p = 0.33)。在佩戴一周结束时,AquaRelease的主观初始、日末、总体舒适度和视力评分均显著优于欧舒适B(p < 0.01)。
奈非康A镜片释放额外的未功能化PVA似乎能提高隐形眼镜佩戴的舒适度。