Goldenberg Georg, Karnath Hans-Otto
Neuropsychological Department, Bogenhausen Hospital, D-81925 Munich, Germany.
J Neurosci. 2006 Jun 7;26(23):6282-7. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0638-06.2006.
Imitation is an important constituent of the behavioral repertoire of human beings. We use imitation for learning motor skills, for facilitating comprehension of other persons' actions and mental states, and as a communicative reference to actions or people. Although some non-human species display imitative behaviors, none of them equals the versatility and perfection of human imitation. The versatility and apparent ease of human imitation is, however, not at all self-evident when one considers the neural and cognitive transformations that must be accomplished for successful imitation. Imitation of meaningless gestures poses a particular challenge for our brain, because similarity between the body of the model and one's own body must bridge fundamental differences between the perspective and modalities of perceiving and controlling one's own and other bodies. We analyzed the locations of left-hemisphere lesions disturbing imitation of meaningless gestures and found a clear-cut body part specificity. Disturbed imitation of finger postures was associated with anterior lesions including the opercular portion of the inferior frontal gyrus, whereas disturbed imitation of hand postures was associated with posterior lesions affecting the inferior parietal lobule and temporo-parieto-occipital junction. These locations do not correspond with known somatotopic maps of motor representations. Rather, they argue for an intermediate step of processing interpolated between perception and execution of gestures as has been suggested by the mirror neuron and the body part coding hypotheses.
模仿是人类行为技能库的重要组成部分。我们通过模仿来学习运动技能,促进对他人行为和心理状态的理解,并作为对行为或人物的一种交流参照。尽管一些非人类物种也表现出模仿行为,但它们都无法与人类模仿的多样性和完美程度相媲美。然而,当人们考虑到成功模仿必须完成的神经和认知转换时,人类模仿的多样性和明显的轻松程度一点也不显而易见。模仿无意义的手势对我们的大脑提出了特殊的挑战,因为模型身体与自身身体之间的相似性必须跨越感知和控制自身身体与他人身体在视角和模态上的根本差异。我们分析了干扰无意义手势模仿的左半球损伤位置,发现了明确的身体部位特异性。手指姿势模仿受干扰与包括额下回岛盖部在内的前部损伤有关,而手部姿势模仿受干扰与影响顶下小叶和颞顶枕交界区的后部损伤有关。这些位置与已知的运动表征躯体定位图不相符。相反,它们支持了镜像神经元和身体部位编码假说所提出的在手势感知和执行之间插入的中间处理步骤。