Kenna George A, Nielsen Darci M, Mello Patricia, Schiesl Alison, Swift Robert M
Department of Community Health, Center for Alcohol and Addiction Studies, Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island, USA.
CNS Drugs. 2007;21(3):213-37. doi: 10.2165/00023210-200721030-00003.
The US FDA has approved a limited number of treatments for alcohol, nicotine and opioid dependence; however, no treatments for other abused drugs such as marijuana, cocaine or methamphetamine are approved. This review focuses on research into drug pharmacotherapies, particularly single-drug therapies, for substance abuse and dependence contributing to the most important dual substance use disorders (SUDs). Given the implications of poly-substance abuse, it is essential that clinicians and researchers be aware of potential pharmacotherapies for the treatment of dual SUDs.A substantial number of patients abuse more than one drug concurrently, complicating the treatment of SUD and leaving clinicians with few FDA-approved drug options for their patients. In this era of evidence-based medicine, such patients are typically treated with therapeutically proven medications, but in ways that are outside the scope of a drug's original indication by the FDA. Such 'off-label' prescribing has become an important therapeutic strategy for practitioners seeking treatments for other diseases in subpopulations such as paediatrics and gerontology or for medical conditions such as oncology or mental illness. Similarly, the information that most clinicians use to make their decisions for treating patients abusing multiple drugs stems from trials treating a single SUD, anecdotal experiences from their own practice or that of their colleagues, or single-case studies reported in the literature. The existing evidence suggests there are few treatments for SUDs that confer significant reductions in substance use across a broad patient population. Moreover, even fewer clinical efficacy trials have been conducted that provide evidence of therapeutic benefit for these drugs. Recognising the difficulty in making the proper drug choice for facilitating maximum treatment success, this review highlights the single drugs or drug combinations that show some potential for treating dual SUDs. This review finds strongest support for the use of disulfiram for treatment of alcohol and cocaine dependence (with or without concomitant methadone maintenance), baclofen for alcohol and cocaine dependence (but not opioid-dependent cocaine users), tiagabine for cocaine dependence in methadone-maintained patients, and topiramate for alcohol, nicotine and cocaine dependence. While ondansetron and olanzapine show some efficacy in treating alcohol and cocaine dependence, more research is needed to better delineate the subpopulation in which these drugs may provide their maximum effect.
美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)已批准了有限数量的针对酒精、尼古丁和阿片类药物依赖的治疗方法;然而,对于其他滥用药物,如大麻、可卡因或甲基苯丙胺,尚未批准任何治疗方法。本综述聚焦于药物疗法的研究,尤其是单一药物疗法,用于治疗导致最重要的双重物质使用障碍(SUDs)的药物滥用和依赖问题。鉴于多物质滥用的影响,临床医生和研究人员必须了解治疗双重SUDs的潜在药物疗法。大量患者同时滥用多种药物,这使SUD的治疗变得复杂,并且留给临床医生的经FDA批准的药物选择很少。在这个循证医学时代,这类患者通常使用经治疗验证的药物进行治疗,但方式超出了FDA规定的药物原始适应症范围。这种“超说明书”用药已成为从业者为儿科和老年医学等亚人群中的其他疾病或肿瘤学或精神疾病等医疗状况寻求治疗方法的重要治疗策略。同样,大多数临床医生用于为滥用多种药物的患者做出治疗决策的信息,源于治疗单一SUD的试验、他们自己或同事实践中的轶事经验,或文献中报道的单病例研究。现有证据表明,几乎没有治疗SUDs的方法能在广泛的患者群体中显著减少物质使用。此外,进行的临床疗效试验更少,无法为这些药物的治疗益处提供证据。认识到在做出正确的药物选择以促进最大治疗成功方面存在困难,本综述强调了显示出治疗双重SUDs潜力的单一药物或药物组合。本综述发现,对于使用双硫仑治疗酒精和可卡因依赖(无论是否同时进行美沙酮维持治疗)、巴氯芬治疗酒精和可卡因依赖(但不包括阿片类药物依赖的可卡因使用者)、替加宾治疗美沙酮维持治疗患者中的可卡因依赖以及托吡酯治疗酒精、尼古丁和可卡因依赖,有最有力的支持。虽然昂丹司琼和奥氮平在治疗酒精和可卡因依赖方面显示出一定疗效,但需要更多研究来更好地界定这些药物可能产生最大效果的亚人群。