Davy Brenda M, Van Walleghen Emily L, Orr Jeb S
Department of Human Nutrition, Foods and Exercise, 221 Wallace Hall (0430), Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA.
Appetite. 2007 Jul;49(1):141-7. doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2007.01.010. Epub 2007 Feb 11.
The purpose of this investigation was to determine if energy intake compensation is more accurate in males compared to females matched for age, habitual physical activity, cardiorespiratory fitness, and dietary cognitive restraint. Healthy, nonobese young men (n=12) and women (n=12) were provided with an ad libitum lunch meal on two occasions. Thirty minutes prior to the lunch meals, subjects were given either a yogurt preload (YP; 500 mL, 1988 kJ, men; 375 mL, 1507 kJ, women) or no preload (NP). Energy intake at the two lunch meals was measured. Visual analog scales were used to assess changes in hunger and fullness. Blood glucose concentrations were also determined. Energy intake compensation for the YP was significantly more accurate in the male compared to the female subjects (86.2+/-5.0 vs. 73.6+/-4.8% compensation). There were no sex differences in perceptions of hunger and satiety. In the pooled sample, hunger ratings were significantly higher in the NP condition, but there were no significant differences in fullness ratings between test meals. In the YP condition, glycemic response to the preload and the ad libitum meal was significantly higher in males compared to females. These results suggest that under acute test meal conditions, energy intake regulation is more accurate in males. Relative inability to regulate energy intake may predispose females to gain weight over time.
本研究的目的是确定与年龄、习惯性身体活动、心肺适能和饮食认知抑制相匹配的女性相比,男性的能量摄入补偿是否更准确。健康、非肥胖的年轻男性(n = 12)和女性(n = 12)分两次提供随意午餐。在午餐前30分钟,受试者要么接受酸奶预负荷(YP;男性500毫升,1988千焦;女性375毫升,1507千焦),要么不接受预负荷(NP)。测量两次午餐时的能量摄入。使用视觉模拟量表评估饥饿和饱腹感的变化。还测定了血糖浓度。与女性受试者相比,男性对YP的能量摄入补偿明显更准确(补偿率分别为86.2±5.0%和73.6±4.8%)。在饥饿和饱腹感的感知方面没有性别差异。在汇总样本中,NP组的饥饿评分显著更高,但测试餐之间的饱腹感评分没有显著差异。在YP组中,男性对预负荷和随意餐的血糖反应明显高于女性。这些结果表明,在急性测试餐条件下,男性的能量摄入调节更准确。相对无法调节能量摄入可能使女性随着时间推移更容易体重增加。