Ndyomugyenyi Richard, Magnussen Pascal, Clarke Siân
Vector Control, Division, Ministry of Health, Kampala, Uganda.
Malar J. 2007 Apr 2;6:39. doi: 10.1186/1475-2875-6-39.
Early recognition of symptoms and signs perceived as malaria are important for effective case management, as few laboratories are available at peripheral health facilities. The validity and reliability of clinical signs and symptoms used by health workers to diagnose malaria were assessed in an area of low transmission in south-western Uganda.
The study had two components: 1) passive case detection where all patients attending the out patient clinic with a febrile illness were included and 2) a longitudinal active malaria case detection survey was conducted in selected villages. A malaria case was defined as any slide-confirmed parasitaemia in a person with an axillary temperature > or = 37.5 degrees C or a history of fever within the last 24 hrs and no signs suggestive of other diseases.
Cases of malaria were significantly more likely to report joint pains, headache, vomiting and abdominal pains. However, due to the low prevalence of malaria, the predictive values of these individual signs alone, or in combination, were poor. Only 24.8% of 1627 patients had malaria according to case definition and > 75% of patients were unnecessarily treated for malaria and few slide negative cases received alternative treatment.
In low-transmission areas, more attention needs to be paid to differential diagnosis of febrile illnesses In view of suggested changes in anti-malarial drug policy, introducing costly artemisinin combination therapy accurate, rapid diagnostic tools are necessary to target treatment to people in need.
由于基层卫生机构中可用的实验室较少,早期识别被视为疟疾的症状和体征对于有效的病例管理很重要。在乌干达西南部一个低传播地区,评估了卫生工作者用于诊断疟疾的临床体征和症状的有效性和可靠性。
该研究有两个部分:1)被动病例检测,纳入所有到门诊就诊的发热疾病患者;2)在选定村庄进行纵向主动疟疾病例检测调查。疟疾病例定义为腋窝温度≥37.5摄氏度或过去24小时内有发热史且无其他疾病体征的患者中任何经涂片确认的寄生虫血症。
疟疾病例更有可能报告关节疼痛、头痛、呕吐和腹痛。然而,由于疟疾患病率较低,这些单独或组合的体征的预测价值较差。根据病例定义,1627名患者中只有24.8%患有疟疾,超过75%的患者接受了不必要的疟疾治疗,很少有涂片阴性病例接受替代治疗。
在低传播地区,鉴于抗疟药物政策的建议变化,需要更加关注发热疾病的鉴别诊断,引入昂贵的青蒿素联合疗法,准确、快速的诊断工具对于将治疗靶向有需要的人群是必要的。