Drewnowski Adam, Monsivais Pablo, Maillot Matthieu, Darmon Nicole
School of Public Health and Community Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA.
J Am Diet Assoc. 2007 Jun;107(6):1028-32. doi: 10.1016/j.jada.2007.03.013.
Low-energy-density diets are often recommended for weight control. Such diets have a higher nutrient content than do high-energy-density diets. This study tested the hypothesis that energy-dense diets have a relatively low monetary cost, whereas less energy-dense diets are more expensive. In this cross-sectional study, dietary intakes of 1,474 French adults (672 men, 802 women), aged 15 to 92 years, were assessed using 7-day diet records. Dietary energy density (kcal/g) was calculated by dividing total dietary energy by the edible weight of foods and caloric beverages consumed. Diet cost ($/7 days or $/2,000 kcal) was estimated using mean national food prices for 895 foods. The relationship between dietary energy density and diet cost was examined in a linear regression model. Within each quintile of energy intakes, the more energy-dense diets were associated with lower diet quality and with lower diet costs (r(2)=0.38 to 0.44). In a regression model, the more energy-dense diets cost less, whereas low-energy-density diets cost substantially more, adjusting for energy intakes, sex, and age. The finding that energy-dense diets cost less per 2,000 kcal may help explain why the highest rates of obesity are observed among groups of limited economic means. The finding that low-energy-density diets are associated with higher diet costs suggests that lasting improvements in diet quality may require economic as well as behavioral interventions.
低能量密度饮食通常被推荐用于控制体重。这类饮食的营养成分比高能量密度饮食更高。本研究检验了以下假设:能量密集型饮食的货币成本相对较低,而能量密度较低的饮食则更昂贵。在这项横断面研究中,使用7天饮食记录评估了1474名年龄在15至92岁之间的法国成年人(672名男性,802名女性)的饮食摄入量。饮食能量密度(千卡/克)通过将总饮食能量除以所摄入食物和含热量饮料的可食用重量来计算。饮食成本(美元/7天或美元/2000千卡)使用895种食物的全国平均食品价格进行估算。在一个线性回归模型中研究了饮食能量密度与饮食成本之间的关系。在每个能量摄入五分位数内,能量密度越高的饮食与较低的饮食质量和较低的饮食成本相关(r² = 0.38至0.44)。在一个回归模型中,调整能量摄入、性别和年龄后,能量密度越高的饮食成本越低,而低能量密度饮食的成本则高得多。每2000千卡能量密集型饮食成本较低这一发现,可能有助于解释为什么在经济条件有限的人群中肥胖率最高。低能量密度饮食与较高饮食成本相关这一发现表明,饮食质量的持久改善可能需要经济和行为干预。