Pilu Alessandra, Sorba Manlio, Hardoy Maria Carolina, Floris Anna Laura, Mannu Francesca, Seruis Maria Luisa, Velluti Claudio, Carpiniello Bernardo, Salvi Massimiliano, Carta Mauro Giovanni
Department of Public Health, University of Cagliari, Via Porcell 4, 09100 Cagliari, Italy.
Clin Pract Epidemiol Ment Health. 2007 Jul 9;3:8. doi: 10.1186/1745-0179-3-8.
No controlled trials have evaluated the long term efficacy of exercise activity to improve the treatment of patients with Major Depressive Disorders. The aim of the present study was to confirm the efficacy of the adjunctive physical activity in the treatment of major depressive disorders, with a long term follow up (8 months).
Trial with randomized naturalistic control. Patients selected from the clinical activity registries of the Psychiatric Unit of the University of Cagliari, Italy.
female, between 40 and 60 years, diagnosis of Major Depressive Disorders (DSM-IV TR) resistant to the ongoing treatment.
diagnosis of psychotic disorders; any contraindications to physical activity.30 patients (71.4% of the eligible) participated to the study.
10 randomized patients undergoing pharmacological treatment plus physical activity.
20 patients undergoing only pharmacological therapy.The following tools were collected from each patient by two different psychiatric physicians at baseline and 8 month after the beginning of exercise program: SCID-I, HAM-D, CGI (Clinical Global Impression), GAF.
The patients that made physical activity had their HAM-D, GAF and CGI score improved from T0 to T8, all differences were statistically significant. In the control group HAM-D, GAF and CGI scores do not show any statistically significant differences between T0 and T8.
Small sample size limited to female in adult age; control group was not subject to any structured rehabilitation activity or placebo so it was impossible to evaluate if the improvement was due to a non specific therapeutic effect associated with taking part in a social activity.
Physical activity seems a good adjunctive treatment in the long term management of patients with MDD. Randomized placebo controlled trials are needed to confirm the results.
尚无对照试验评估运动活动改善重度抑郁症患者治疗效果的长期疗效。本研究的目的是通过长期随访(8个月),确认辅助体育活动在治疗重度抑郁症中的疗效。
采用随机自然对照试验。从意大利卡利亚里大学精神病科的临床活动登记中选取患者。
女性,年龄在40至60岁之间,诊断为对当前治疗有抵抗性的重度抑郁症(DSM-IV TR)。
精神病性障碍诊断;任何身体活动的禁忌症。30名患者(符合条件者的71.4%)参与了研究。
10名随机分组的患者接受药物治疗加体育活动。
20名患者仅接受药物治疗。在基线和运动计划开始8个月后,由两名不同的精神科医生从每位患者处收集以下工具:SCID-I、HAM-D、CGI(临床总体印象)、GAF。
进行体育活动的患者其HAM-D、GAF和CGI评分从T0到T8有所改善,所有差异均具有统计学意义。在对照组中,HAM-D、GAF和CGI评分在T0和T8之间未显示任何统计学显著差异。
样本量小,仅限于成年女性;对照组未接受任何结构化康复活动或安慰剂,因此无法评估改善是否归因于参与社交活动相关的非特异性治疗效果。
体育活动似乎是重度抑郁症患者长期管理中的一种良好辅助治疗方法。需要进行随机安慰剂对照试验来证实结果。