Seery Carol Hubbard, Watkins Ruth V, Mangelsdorf Sarah C, Shigeto Aya
University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Comm. Sciences and Disorders Department, P.O. Box 413, Enderis Hall 873, Milwaukee, WI 53201, USA.
J Fluency Disord. 2007;32(3):197-217. doi: 10.1016/j.jfludis.2007.07.001. Epub 2007 Jul 18.
This paper is the second in a series of two articles exploring subtypes of stuttering, and it addresses the question of whether and how language ability and temperament variables may be relevant to the study of subtypes within the larger population of children who stutter. Despite observations of varied profiles among young children who stutter, efforts to identify and characterize subtypes of stuttering have had limited influence on theoretical or clinical understanding of the disorder. This manuscript briefly highlights research on language and temperament in young children who stutter, and considers whether the results can provide guidance for efforts to more effectively investigate and elucidate subtypes in childhood stuttering. Issues from the literature that appear relevant to research on stuttering subtypes include: (a) the question of whether stuttering is best characterized as categorical or continuous; (b) interpretation of individual differences in skills and profiles; and (c) the fact that, during the preschool years, the interaction among domains such as language and temperament are changing very rapidly, resulting in large differences in developmental profiles within relatively brief chronological age periods.
The reader will be able to: (1) discuss possible associations of language ability and temperament to the development of stuttering in young children; (2) summarize the subtyping research from the literature on language ability and temperament in young children; (3) generate directions for future research of stuttering subtypes drawn from the literature related to language ability and temperament in young children.
本文是探讨口吃亚型的两篇系列文章中的第二篇,它探讨了语言能力和气质变量是否以及如何与口吃儿童总体人群中的亚型研究相关这一问题。尽管观察到口吃幼儿存在不同的特征,但识别和描述口吃亚型的努力对该障碍的理论或临床理解影响有限。本手稿简要强调了口吃幼儿语言和气质方面的研究,并考虑这些结果是否可为更有效地研究和阐明儿童口吃亚型的努力提供指导。文献中与口吃亚型研究相关的问题包括:(a)口吃最好被描述为分类的还是连续的问题;(b)对技能和特征个体差异的解释;以及(c)在学前阶段,语言和气质等领域之间的相互作用变化非常迅速,导致在相对较短的实际年龄期间发育特征存在很大差异。
读者将能够:(1)讨论语言能力和气质与幼儿口吃发展的可能关联;(2)总结文献中关于幼儿语言能力和气质的亚型研究;(3)从与幼儿语言能力和气质相关的文献中得出口吃亚型未来研究的方向。