Rossiter Kate, Kontos Pia, Colantonio Angela, Gilbert Julie, Gray Julia, Keightley Michelle
Public Health Sciences, University of Toronto, 155 College Street, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5T 3M7.
Soc Sci Med. 2008 Jan;66(1):130-46. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2007.07.021. Epub 2007 Sep 11.
Over the past several decades, researchers have taken an interest in theatre as a unique method of analysing data and translating findings. Because of its ability to communicate research findings in an emotive and embodied manner, theatre holds particular potential for health research, which often engages complex questions of the human condition. In order to evaluate the research potential of theatre, this article critically examines examples of evaluated health research studies that have used theatre for the purposes of data analysis or translation. We examine these studies from two perspectives. First, the literature is divided and categorized into four theatre genres: (1) non-theatrical performances; (2) ethnodramas, which can be interactive or non-interactive; (3) theatrical research-based performances; and (4) fictional theatrical performances. This categorization highlights the importance of these genres of theatre and provides an analysis of the benefits and disadvantages of each, thus providing insight into how theatre may be most effectively utilized in health research. Second, we explore the efficacy of using theatre for the purposes of data analysis and knowledge transfer, and critically examine potential approaches to the evaluation of such endeavours.
在过去几十年里,研究人员对戏剧作为一种独特的数据分析和研究结果转化方法产生了兴趣。由于戏剧能够以情感化和具身化的方式传达研究结果,它在健康研究中具有特殊潜力,因为健康研究常常涉及人类状况的复杂问题。为了评估戏剧的研究潜力,本文批判性地审视了已评估的健康研究案例,这些研究将戏剧用于数据分析或结果转化的目的。我们从两个角度审视这些研究。首先,文献被划分并归类为四种戏剧类型:(1)非戏剧表演;(2)民族志戏剧,可分为互动型或非互动型;(3)基于戏剧研究的表演;(4)虚构戏剧表演。这种分类突出了这些戏剧类型的重要性,并对每种类型的优缺点进行了分析,从而深入了解如何在健康研究中最有效地利用戏剧。其次,我们探讨了将戏剧用于数据分析和知识转移目的的有效性,并批判性地审视评估此类工作的潜在方法。