Rolider A, Cummings A, Van Houten R
Department of Psychiatry, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
J Appl Behav Anal. 1991 Winter;24(4):763-73. doi: 10.1901/jaba.1991.24-763.
The effects of therapeutic punishment delivered following inappropriate behavior on the academic responding and eye-to-face contact of 2 persons with developmental handicaps was examined using a counterbalanced alternating treatment design. Each subject was sequentially taught by two therapists each day. While one of the therapists taught the subject, the second therapist stood in close proximity directly behind the subject. During baseline, neither therapist delivered punishment following inappropriate behavior. During the treatment condition, one of the therapists delivered all punishment regardless of whether she was teaching or standing behind the subject. The therapist who delivered all punishment for 1 subject did not deliver any punishment for the other subject. During the last condition, the therapist delivering all punishment was reversed for 1 of the subjects. The results indicated that the task being taught was mastered by each subject only when the therapist delivering punishment was teaching. Data collected also indicated that each subject made more eye-to-face contact when the therapist delivering all punishment was teaching. Although neither therapist had to deliver punishers often, punishment had to be administered less often when the therapist teaching the subject was also the therapist delivering punishment.
采用平衡交替治疗设计,考察了对两名发育障碍患者在出现不适当行为后实施治疗性惩罚,对其学业反应和目光对视的影响。每天由两名治疗师依次对每名受试者进行教导。当一名治疗师教导受试者时,第二名治疗师紧挨着站在受试者身后。在基线期,两名治疗师都不会在出现不适当行为后实施惩罚。在治疗阶段,其中一名治疗师无论在教导受试者还是站在受试者身后,都会实施所有惩罚。对一名受试者实施所有惩罚的治疗师,对另一名受试者则不实施任何惩罚。在最后一个阶段,对其中一名受试者而言,实施所有惩罚的治疗师进行了对调。结果表明,只有当实施惩罚的治疗师在教导受试者时,每名受试者才能掌握所教授的任务。收集到的数据还表明,当实施所有惩罚的治疗师在教导受试者时,每名受试者的目光对视更多。尽管两名治疗师都不必经常实施惩罚,但当教导受试者的治疗师也是实施惩罚的治疗师时,惩罚的实施频率更低。