Berthomier Christian, Drouot Xavier, Herman-Stoïca Maria, Berthomier Pierre, Prado Jacques, Bokar-Thire Djibril, Benoit Odile, Mattout Jérémie, d'Ortho Marie-Pia
PHYSIP SA, Paris, France.
Sleep. 2007 Nov;30(11):1587-95. doi: 10.1093/sleep/30.11.1587.
To assess the performance of automatic sleep scoring software (ASEEGA) based on a single EEG channel comparatively with manual scoring (2 experts) of conventional full polysomnograms.
Polysomnograms from 15 healthy individuals were scored by 2 independent experts using conventional R&K rules. The results were compared to those of ASEEGA scoring on an epoch-by-epoch basis.
Sleep laboratory in the physiology department of a teaching hospital.
Fifteen healthy volunteers.
The epoch-by-epoch comparison was based on classifying into 2 states (wake/sleep), 3 states (wake/REM/ NREM), 4 states (wake/REM/stages 1-2/SWS), or 5 states (wake/REM/ stage 1/stage 2/SWS). The obtained overall agreements, as quantified by the kappa coefficient, were 0.82, 0.81, 0.75, and 0.72, respectively. Furthermore, obtained agreements between ASEEGA and the expert consensual scoring were 96.0%, 92.1%, 84.9%, and 82.9%, respectively. Finally, when classifying into 5 states, the sensitivity and positive predictive value of ASEEGA regarding wakefulness were 82.5% and 89.7%, respectively. Similarly, sensitivity and positive predictive value regarding REM state were 83.0% and 89.1%.
Our results establish the face validity and convergent validity of ASEEGA for single-channel sleep analysis in healthy individuals. ASEEGA appears as a good candidate for diagnostic aid and automatic ambulant scoring.
比较基于单通道脑电图(EEG)的自动睡眠评分软件(ASEEGA)与传统全夜多导睡眠图人工评分(由2位专家进行)的性能。
15名健康个体的多导睡眠图由2位独立专家按照传统的R&K规则进行评分。将结果与ASEEGA逐段评分结果进行比较。
一家教学医院生理科的睡眠实验室。
15名健康志愿者。
逐段比较基于将睡眠分为2种状态(清醒/睡眠)、3种状态(清醒/快速眼动睡眠/非快速眼动睡眠)、4种状态(清醒/快速眼动睡眠/1-2期睡眠/慢波睡眠)或5种状态(清醒/快速眼动睡眠/1期睡眠/2期睡眠/慢波睡眠)。通过kappa系数量化得到的总体一致性分别为0.82、0.81、0.75和0.72。此外,ASEEGA与专家共识评分之间的一致性分别为96.0%、92.1%、84.9%和82.9%。最后,在分为5种状态时,ASEEGA对清醒状态的敏感性和阳性预测值分别为82.5%和89.7%。同样,对快速眼动睡眠状态的敏感性和阳性预测值分别为83.0%和89.1%。
我们的结果确立了ASEEGA在健康个体单通道睡眠分析中的表面效度和收敛效度。ASEEGA似乎是诊断辅助和自动动态评分的良好候选工具。