Butler Andrea, Oruc Ipek, Fox Christopher J, Barton Jason J S
Faculty of Medicine, University of British Columbia, Vancouver BC, Canada.
Brain Res. 2008 Jan 29;1191:116-26. doi: 10.1016/j.brainres.2007.10.101. Epub 2007 Nov 12.
Previous studies have demonstrated the existence of adaptation aftereffects for facial expressions. Here we investigated which aspects of facial stimuli contribute to these aftereffects. In Experiment 1, we examined the role of local adaptation to image elements such as curvature, shape and orientation, independent of expression, by using hybrid faces constructed from either the same or opposing expressions. While hybrid faces made with consistent expressions generated aftereffects as large as those with normal faces, there were no aftereffects from hybrid faces made from different expressions, despite the fact that these contained the same local image elements. In Experiment 2, we examined the role of facial features independent of the normal face configuration by contrasting adaptation with whole faces to adaptation with scrambled faces. We found that scrambled faces also generated significant aftereffects, indicating that expressive features without a normal facial configuration could generate expression aftereffects. In Experiment 3, we examined the role of facial configuration by using schematic faces made from line elements that in isolation do not carry expression-related information (e.g. curved segments and straight lines) but that convey an expression when arranged in a normal facial configuration. We obtained a significant aftereffect for facial configurations but not scrambled configurations of these line elements. We conclude that facial expression aftereffects are not due to local adaptation to image elements but due to high-level adaptation of neural representations that involve both facial features and facial configuration.
以往的研究已经证明了面部表情存在适应后效。在此,我们探究了面部刺激的哪些方面会导致这些后效。在实验1中,我们通过使用由相同或相反表情构建的混合面孔,研究了局部适应图像元素(如曲率、形状和方向)的作用,而不考虑表情。虽然由一致表情制作的混合面孔产生的后效与正常面孔产生的后效一样大,但由不同表情制作的混合面孔却没有产生后效,尽管这些混合面孔包含相同的局部图像元素。在实验2中,我们通过对比对完整面孔的适应与对打乱面孔的适应,研究了独立于正常面部结构的面部特征的作用。我们发现打乱的面孔也产生了显著的后效,这表明没有正常面部结构的表情特征也能产生表情后效。在实验3中,我们通过使用由线条元素制成的示意性面孔来研究面部结构的作用,这些线条元素单独来看并不携带与表情相关的信息(如曲线段和直线),但当以正常面部结构排列时会传达一种表情。我们发现这些线条元素的面部结构产生了显著的后效,但打乱的结构则没有。我们得出结论,面部表情后效不是由于对图像元素的局部适应,而是由于涉及面部特征和面部结构的神经表征的高级适应。