Esrey S A, Potash J B, Roberts L, Shiff C
Faculty of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences, Macdonald College, McGill University, Ste-Anne-de-Bellevue, Canada.
Bull World Health Organ. 1991;69(5):609-21.
A total of 144 studies were analysed to examine the impact of improved water supply and sanitation facilities on ascariasis, diarrhoea, dracunculiasis, hookworm infection, schistosomiasis, and trachoma. These diseases were selected because they are widespread and illustrate the variety of mechanisms through which improved water and sanitation can protect people. Disease-specific median reduction levels were calculated for all studies, and separately for the more methodologically rigorous ones. For the latter studies, the median reduction in morbidity for diarrhoea, trachoma, and ascariasis induced by water supplies and/or sanitation was 26%, 27%, and 29%, respectively; the median reduction for schistosomiasis and dracunculiasis was higher, at 77% and 78%, respectively. All studies of hookworm infection were flawed apart from one, which reported a 4% reduction in incidence. For hookworm infection, ascariasis, and schistosomiasis, the reduction in disease severity, as measured in egg counts, was greater than that in incidence or prevalence. Child mortality fell by 55%, which suggests that water and sanitation have a substantial impact on child survival. Water for personal and domestic hygiene was important in reducing the rates of ascariasis, diarrhoea, schistosomiasis, and trachoma. Sanitation facilities decreased diarrhoea morbidity and mortality and the severity of hookworm infection. Better water quality reduced the incidence of dracunculiasis, but its role in diarrhoeal disease control was less important than that of sanitation and hygiene.
共分析了144项研究,以检验改善供水和卫生设施对蛔虫病、腹泻、麦地那龙线虫病、钩虫感染、血吸虫病和沙眼的影响。选择这些疾病是因为它们广泛存在,并说明了改善水和卫生条件可保护人们的多种机制。计算了所有研究中特定疾病的中位数降低水平,并分别计算了方法上更严谨的研究的中位数降低水平。对于后一类研究,供水和/或卫生设施导致的腹泻、沙眼和蛔虫病发病率的中位数降低分别为26%、27%和29%;血吸虫病和麦地那龙线虫病的中位数降低更高,分别为77%和78%。除一项报告发病率降低4%的研究外,所有钩虫感染研究均存在缺陷。对于钩虫感染、蛔虫病和血吸虫病,以虫卵计数衡量的疾病严重程度的降低大于发病率或患病率的降低。儿童死亡率下降了55%,这表明水和卫生设施对儿童生存有重大影响。用于个人和家庭卫生的水对于降低蛔虫病、腹泻、血吸虫病和沙眼的发病率很重要。卫生设施降低了腹泻的发病率和死亡率以及钩虫感染的严重程度。更好的水质降低了麦地那龙线虫病的发病率,但其在控制腹泻病方面的作用不如卫生设施和个人卫生重要。