Thiel David D, Francis Paula, Heckman Michael G, Winfield Howard N
Department of Urology, University of Iowa, Hospitals and Clinics, Iowa City, Iowa 52242, USA.
J Endourol. 2008 Jun;22(6):1331-8. doi: 10.1089/end.2008.0023.
A current dilemma is how to incorporate robot assisted laparoscopic radical prostatectomy (RALP) into residency/fellowship programs while containing costs and maintaining acceptable operative times. We prospectively analyzed factors that affect the time of nine separate RALP steps performed in a residency/fellowship training program incorporating the da Vinci robot.
A prospective evaluation of 50 consecutive RALP performed by a single surgeon while incorporating trainees was completed. RALP was divided into nine segments, and time of each segment was recorded in minutes. Who performed each portion of the procedure (resident, fellow, or attending surgeon) was also analyzed. The effects of clinical and prostate cancer characteristics were analyzed statistically to investigate associations with procedure completion times for each of the nine segments. Outcomes, including complications and urinary continence, were recorded.
Mean age was 58 years, and body mass index was 30 kg/m(2). Mean prostate size was 49.2 grams. Nine patients (18%) had pathologic T(3) disease, and 10 patients (20%) had positive surgical margins. Median total operative time was 276 minutes (range 245-330 min). There was no statistical association with any clinical parameter prolonging total operative time or those of the nine individual steps of the operation. Locally weighted smooth time plots demonstrate stable decreases in all segments with experience. The slowest decreases were seen in bladder neck and neurovascular bundle times. Anastomosis time fluctuated the most.
RALP can be incorporated successfully into a residency/fellowship training program with acceptable operative times and outcomes even while the supervising physician is on his "learning curve."
当前的一个难题是如何将机器人辅助腹腔镜根治性前列腺切除术(RALP)纳入住院医师/专科培训项目,同时控制成本并保持可接受的手术时间。我们前瞻性地分析了在一个使用达芬奇机器人的住院医师/专科培训项目中,影响九个独立RALP步骤时间的因素。
对一位外科医生在带教实习生时连续进行的50例RALP进行了前瞻性评估。RALP被分为九个部分,每个部分的时间以分钟记录。还分析了手术各部分由谁执行(住院医师、专科医师或主治医生)。对临床和前列腺癌特征的影响进行了统计学分析,以研究与九个部分中每个部分手术完成时间的相关性。记录了包括并发症和尿失禁在内的结果。
平均年龄为58岁,体重指数为30kg/m²。平均前列腺大小为49.2克。9例患者(占18%)有病理T3期疾病,10例患者(占20%)手术切缘阳性。中位总手术时间为276分钟(范围245 - 330分钟)。延长总手术时间的任何临床参数或手术九个单独步骤的参数与总手术时间均无统计学关联。局部加权平滑时间图显示,随着经验增加,所有部分的时间均稳定下降。膀胱颈和神经血管束部分时间下降最慢。吻合时间波动最大。
即使在指导医师仍处于“学习曲线”阶段时,RALP也能成功纳入住院医师/专科培训项目,并具有可接受的手术时间和结果。