Severens Els, Jansma Bernadette M, Hartsuiker Robert J
Department of Experimental Psychology, Ghent University, H. Dunantlaan 2, 9000 Gent, Belgium.
Brain Res. 2008 Sep 4;1228:135-44. doi: 10.1016/j.brainres.2008.05.092. Epub 2008 Jul 2.
Event-related potentials were used to study whether factors known to influence subject-verb number agreement in production exert analogous effects on sentence comprehension. Participants read Dutch sentences containing subject-verb number agreement errors while their brainwaves were measured. The determiner of the singular head noun could be ambiguous or unambiguous in number and the modifier ("local") noun could be plural or singular. Both ambiguity and number match affect error rates in production. We expected evoked potentials in response to the verb to be modulated by number ambiguity; larger effects were expected when the sentences started with an unambiguous determiner. When the local noun was singular, we observed a more negative wave elicited by the incorrect verbs compared to the correct verbs in the 350-400 ms time-window. This effect was largest when the head noun phrase contained no number ambiguity. When the local noun was plural the waves were more positive for incorrect verbs than for correct verbs in the 600-650 ms time-window. Again this effect was largest when the head noun phrase contained no number ambiguity. Most importantly, the results show that agreement computation in comprehension is influenced by the same factors as in production. We further suggest that in the sentences with a singular local noun there is a shallow analysis of the sentence, but the sentences with a plural local noun require a deeper syntactic analysis.
事件相关电位被用于研究已知在产出中影响主谓数一致的因素是否在句子理解中产生类似的效果。参与者阅读包含主谓数一致错误的荷兰语句子,同时测量他们的脑电波。单数中心名词的限定词在数上可以是模糊的或明确的,修饰语(“局部”)名词可以是复数或单数。模糊性和数的匹配都会影响产出中的错误率。我们预期对动词的诱发电位会受到数的模糊性的调制;当句子以明确的限定词开头时,预期会有更大的影响。当局部名词是单数时,在350 - 400毫秒的时间窗口内,我们观察到与正确动词相比,错误动词引发的波形更负。当中心名词短语不存在数的模糊性时,这种效应最大。当局部名词是复数时,在600 - 650毫秒的时间窗口内,错误动词的波形比正确动词的波形更正。同样,当中心名词短语不存在数的模糊性时,这种效应最大。最重要的是,结果表明理解中的一致计算受到与产出中相同因素的影响。我们进一步表明,在局部名词为单数的句子中存在对句子的浅层分析,但局部名词为复数的句子需要更深入的句法分析。