Yanovich Ran, Evans Rachel, Israeli Eran, Constantini Naama, Sharvit Nurit, Merkel Drorit, Epstein Yoram, Moran Daniel S
Heller Institute of Medical Research, Sheba Medical Center, Tel-Hashomer, Israel.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2008 Nov;40(11 Suppl):S654-9. doi: 10.1249/MSS.0b013e3181893f30.
To evaluate gender differences in physical fitness before and after a 4-month gender-integrated basic training (BT) course and to determine whether this program effectively narrowed the differences between male and female soldiers in physical fitness parameters.
One hundred and thirty-seven soldiers (109 females and 28 males) successfully completed a 4-month BT course in the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). The subject's physical fitness was evaluated pre- and post-BT by three laboratory tests [the maximal aerobic capacity (VO2max), the Leonardo Ground Reaction Force Plate, and the Wingate Anaerobic Test (WAnT)] and by the IDF physical fitness test (IDF-PT).
Females significantly improved their scores in the IDF-PT and laboratory aerobic tests, whereas males significantly improved only in the IDF-PT. After BT, gender differences narrowed by approximately 4% in all tests except upper body strength. Although fitness improvement after BT was marginally higher in females than males, resulting in a slight narrowing of the gender differences, a significant gender gap in physical fitness still exists after BT.
There was only a small overlap in physical abilities at the beginning of BT, which indicated vast differences in physical fitness between the genders. As expected, integrated combat BT improved physical fitness. Although females demonstrated marginally higher improvement in aerobic capacity, basic physiological gender differences were still evident at the end of the training regimen.
评估为期4个月的性别融合基础训练(BT)课程前后的体能性别差异,并确定该计划是否有效缩小了男女士兵在体能参数上的差异。
137名士兵(109名女性和28名男性)成功完成了以色列国防军(IDF)的4个月BT课程。通过三项实验室测试[最大有氧能力(VO2max)、莱昂纳多地面反作用力板和温盖特无氧测试(WAnT)]以及IDF体能测试(IDF-PT)对受试者训练前后的体能进行评估。
女性在IDF-PT和实验室有氧测试中的成绩显著提高,而男性仅在IDF-PT中显著提高。BT训练后,除上身力量外,所有测试中的性别差异缩小了约4%。尽管BT训练后女性的体能改善略高于男性,导致性别差异略有缩小,但BT训练后体能方面仍存在显著的性别差距。
BT训练开始时,男女体能能力仅有很小的重叠,这表明男女在体能方面存在巨大差异。正如预期的那样,综合战斗BT训练提高了体能。尽管女性在有氧能力方面的改善略高,但在训练结束时,基本的生理性别差异仍然明显。