Booth D C, Deupree R H, Hultgren H N, DeMaria A N, Scott S M, Luchi R J
Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Centers, Lexington, Ky.
Circulation. 1991 Jan;83(1):87-95. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.83.1.87.
To assess the effect of bypass surgery on outcome from unstable angina, 468 patients were randomized to medical treatment (237 patients) or surgery plus medical treatment (231 patients) and have been followed for comparison of survival, cardiac end points, and quality of life; the latter end point is discussed in the present report. Data were available at 3 and 5 years for 80% and 82% of patients in the medical group, respectively, and 77% and 80% of patients in the surgery group, respectively. At 3 months after randomization to therapy, 79.8% of patients in the surgery group reported subjective improvement, compared with 58% of the medical group, 12.6% of the surgery group reported no change compared with 24.5% of the medical group, and 5.5% of the surgery group reported worsening compared with 24.5% of the medical group (p less than 0.01 by chi 2). Similar data were found for chest pain status, and the benefit to the surgery group remained statistically significant through 5 years of follow-up. Crossover rate to surgery was 43% by 5 years. Treadmill duration was increased in the surgery group compared with the medical group (6.5 +/- 0.25 versus 5.3 +/- 0.25 minutes at 6 months, p less than 0.01), and a significant difference was again demonstrated at 3 and 5 years. A trend toward decreased recurrence of unstable angina was present in the surgery group at 1 year (six of 168 [3.6%] versus 13 of 187 [6.9%] in the medical group, p = 0.158), but the two groups were similar at 3 and 5 years.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
为评估搭桥手术对不稳定型心绞痛患者预后的影响,468例患者被随机分为药物治疗组(237例患者)或手术加药物治疗组(231例患者),并对其进行随访,以比较生存率、心脏终点事件和生活质量;本报告讨论了后一个终点事件。药物治疗组分别有80%和82%的患者在3年和5年时有可用数据,手术组分别有77%和80%的患者在3年和5年时有可用数据。在随机接受治疗3个月后,手术组79.8%的患者报告主观症状改善,而药物治疗组为58%;手术组12.6%的患者报告无变化,药物治疗组为24.5%;手术组5.5%的患者报告症状恶化,药物治疗组为24.5%(χ²检验,p<0.01)。胸痛状况也得到了类似的数据,并且在长达5年的随访中,手术组的获益在统计学上仍具有显著意义。到5年时,转至手术治疗的比例为43%。与药物治疗组相比,手术组的平板运动持续时间增加(6个月时为6.5±0.25分钟对5.3±0.25分钟,p<0.01),在3年和5年时再次显示出显著差异。手术组在1年时不稳定型心绞痛复发有减少趋势(168例中有6例[3.6%],而药物治疗组187例中有13例[6.9%],p = 0.158),但在3年和5年时两组相似。(摘要截短于250字)