Korfiatis Panayiotis, Kalogeropoulou Christina, Karahaliou Anna, Kazantzi Alexandra, Skiadopoulos Spyros, Costaridou Lena
Department of Medical Physics, School of Medicine, University of Patras, Patras, Greece.
Med Phys. 2008 Dec;35(12):5290-302. doi: 10.1118/1.3003066.
Accurate and automated lung field (LF) segmentation in high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) is highly challenged by the presence of pathologies affecting lung borders, also affecting the performance of computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) schemes. In this work, a two-dimensional LF segmentation algorithm adapted to interstitial pneumonia (IP) patterns is presented. The algorithm employs k-means clustering followed by a filling operation to obtain an initial LF order estimate. The final LF border is obtained by an iterative support vector machine neighborhood labeling of border pixels based on gray level and wavelet coefficient statistics features. A second feature set based on gray level averaging and gradient features was also investigated to evaluate its effect on segmentation performance of the proposed method. The proposed method is evaluated on a dataset of 22 HRCT cases spanning a range of IP patterns such as ground glass, reticular, and honeycombing. The accuracy of the method is assessed using area overlap and shape differentiation metrics (d(mean), d(rms), and d(max)), by comparing automatically derived lung borders to manually traced ones, and further compared to a gray level thresholding-based (GLT-based) method. Accuracy of the methods evaluated is also compared to interobserver variability. The proposed method incorporating gray level and wavelet coefficient statistics demonstrated the highest segmentation accuracy, averaged over left and right LFs (overlap=0.954, d(mean)=1.080 mm, d(rms)=1.407 mm, and d(max)=4.944 mm), which is statistically significant (two-tailed student's t test for paired data, p<0.0083) with respect to all metrics considered as compared to the proposed method incorporating gray level averaging and gradient features (overlap=0.918, d(mean)=2.354 mm, d(rms)=3.711 mm, and d(max)=14.412 mm) and the GLT-based method (overlap=0.897, d(mean)=3.618 mm, d(rms)=5.007 mm, and d(max)=16.893 mm). The performance of the three segmentation methods, although decreased as IP pattern severity level (mild, moderate, and severe) was increased, did not demonstrate statistically significant difference (two-tailed student's t test for unpaired data, p>0.0167 for all metrics considered). Finally, the accuracy of the proposed method, based on gray level and wavelet coefficient statistics ranges within interobserver variability. The proposed segmentation method could be used as an initial stage of a CAD scheme for IP patterns.
在高分辨率计算机断层扫描(HRCT)中,准确且自动地分割肺野(LF)面临着巨大挑战,因为影响肺边界的病变会干扰分割结果,进而影响计算机辅助诊断(CAD)方案的性能。在这项研究中,我们提出了一种适用于间质性肺炎(IP)模式的二维LF分割算法。该算法采用k均值聚类,随后进行填充操作以获得初始的LF轮廓估计。最终的LF边界通过基于灰度级和小波系数统计特征的边界像素的迭代支持向量机邻域标记来确定。我们还研究了基于灰度级平均和梯度特征的第二个特征集,以评估其对所提方法分割性能的影响。我们在所提出的方法在一个包含22例HRCT病例的数据集上进行了评估,这些病例涵盖了一系列IP模式,如磨玻璃影、网状影和蜂窝状影。通过将自动得出的肺边界与手动描绘的边界进行比较,并进一步与基于灰度阈值化(GLT)的方法进行比较,使用面积重叠和形状差异度量(d(mean)、d(rms)和d(max))来评估该方法的准确性。所评估方法的准确性还与观察者间的变异性进行了比较。结合灰度级和小波系数统计的所提方法表现出最高的分割准确性,左右肺野平均(重叠=0.954,d(mean)=1.080毫米,d(rms)=1.407毫米,d(max)=4.944毫米),与结合灰度级平均和梯度特征的所提方法(重叠=0.918,d(mean)=2.354毫米,d(rms)=3.711毫米,d(max)=14.412毫米)以及基于GLT的方法(重叠=0.897,d(mean)=3.618毫米,d(rms)=5.007毫米,d(max)=16.893毫米)相比,在所有考虑的度量方面具有统计学显著性(配对数据的双尾学生t检验,p<0.0083)。尽管随着IP模式严重程度级别(轻度、中度和重度)的增加,三种分割方法的性能都有所下降,但在所有考虑的度量方面均未显示出统计学显著差异(未配对数据的双尾学生t检验,p>0.0167)。最后,基于灰度级和小波系数统计的所提方法的准确性在观察者间变异性范围内。所提出的分割方法可作为IP模式CAD方案的初始阶段。