Rubinstein Mark L, Benowitz Neal L, Auerback Glenna M, Moscicki Anna-Barbara
Division of Adolescent Medicine, University of California-San Francisco, 3333 California Street, San Francisco, CA 94118, USA.
Nicotine Tob Res. 2009 Feb;11(2):185-9. doi: 10.1093/ntr/ntn028. Epub 2009 Feb 25.
Withdrawal is one of the most important symptoms of nicotine addiction. We examined the extent to which adolescent light smokers experienced withdrawal symptoms when deprived of nicotine for a 24-hr period.
A total of 20 adolescents aged 13-17 years who smoked 1-5 cigarettes/day (CPD) refrained from smoking for a 24-hr period. Withdrawal scales were administered, and heart rate was measured at baseline, 12, and 24 hr. Neuropsychological testing was performed at baseline and 24 hr. Participants were divided into two groups: very light smokers (1-3 CPD) and light smokers (4-5 CPD).
At 12 hr, very light smokers experienced a decrease in withdrawal symptoms versus light smokers, who reported an increase in symptoms (-2.9 vs. 2.8, p = .02). Similarly, at 24 hr, very light smokers experienced a mean decrease in withdrawal score compared with a mean increase for the light smoker group (-2.2 vs. 5.8, p = .04). We did not find a significant change in heart rate or any differences in participants' scores on the memory or concentration tasks.
Based on our findings in this controlled laboratory experiment, adolescent very light smokers did not appear to have significant withdrawal symptoms following abstinence from nicotine. Adolescent light smokers who smoke 4-5 CPD experienced subjective withdrawal symptoms but did not have objective signs of nicotine withdrawal. The stage of smoking in which adolescents are smoking 5 CPD or fewer appears to be a crucial time for studying development of nicotine addiction in teens as they may be transitioning from social smoking to early addiction.
戒断是尼古丁成瘾最重要的症状之一。我们研究了青少年轻度吸烟者在24小时不摄入尼古丁时出现戒断症状的程度。
共有20名年龄在13至17岁之间、每天吸1至5支香烟(日吸烟量)的青少年戒烟24小时。使用戒断量表,并在基线、12小时和24小时测量心率。在基线和24小时进行神经心理学测试。参与者分为两组:极轻度吸烟者(日吸烟量1至3支)和轻度吸烟者(日吸烟量4至5支)。
在12小时时,极轻度吸烟者的戒断症状有所减轻,而轻度吸烟者的症状有所增加(-2.9对2.8,p = 0.02)。同样,在24小时时,极轻度吸烟者的戒断得分平均下降,而轻度吸烟者组平均上升(-2.2对5.8,p = 0.04)。我们没有发现心率有显著变化,也没有发现参与者在记忆或注意力任务上的得分有任何差异。
基于我们在这个对照实验室实验中的发现,青少年极轻度吸烟者在戒除尼古丁后似乎没有明显的戒断症状。每天吸4至5支香烟的青少年轻度吸烟者经历了主观戒断症状,但没有尼古丁戒断的客观迹象。青少年日吸烟量为5支或更少的吸烟阶段似乎是研究青少年尼古丁成瘾发展的关键时期,因为他们可能正从社交性吸烟过渡到早期成瘾阶段。