Department of Public Health, Ghent University, 9000 Gent, Belgium.
Addiction. 2009 Nov;104(11):1918-26. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2009.02686.x. Epub 2009 Aug 6.
To investigate the associations between well-known, cost-effective tobacco control policies at country level and smoking prevalence among 15-year-old adolescents.
Multi-level modelling based on the 2005-06 Health Behaviour in School-aged Children Study, a cross-national study at individual level, and with country-level variables from the Tobacco Control Scale and published country-level databases.
Twenty-nine European countries.
A total of 25 599 boys and 26 509 girls.
Self-reported regular smoking defined as at least weekly smoking, including daily smoking (dichotomous).
Interaction effects between gender and smoking policies were identified, therefore boys and girls were analysed separately. Large cross-national differences in smoking prevalence were documented. Intraclass correlations (ICC) of 0.038 (boys) and 0.035 (girls) were found. In the final multi-level model for boys, besides the significance of the individual variables such as family affluence, country-level affluence and the legality of vending machines were related significantly to regular smoking [b(country affluence) = -0.010; b(partial restriction vending machines) = -0.366, P < 0.05]. Price policy was of borderline significance [b(price policy) = -0.026, P = 0.050]. All relationships were in the expected direction. The model fit is not as good for girls; only the legality of vending machines had a borderline significance in the final model [b(total ban vending machines) = -0.372, P = 0.06].
For boys, some of the currently recommended tobacco control policies may help to reduce smoking prevalence. However, the model is less suitable for girls, indicating gender differences in the potential efficacy of smoking policies. Future research should address this issue.
调查国家层面上知名且具有成本效益的烟草控制政策与 15 岁青少年吸烟率之间的关联。
基于多水平模型,利用 2005-06 年“青少年健康行为研究”的个体层面的跨国研究数据,以及来自“烟草控制量表”和已发表的国家层面数据库的国家层面变量。
29 个欧洲国家。
共有 25599 名男孩和 26509 名女孩。
自我报告的经常吸烟定义为至少每周吸烟,包括每日吸烟(二分变量)。
确定了性别与吸烟政策之间的交互效应,因此分别对男孩和女孩进行了分析。记录到吸烟率存在较大的跨国差异。发现个体变量(如家庭富裕程度、国家富裕程度和自动售货机的合法性)与男孩的常规吸烟之间存在显著相关性(ICC 为 0.038)。在男孩的最终多水平模型中,除了个人变量(如家庭富裕程度、国家富裕程度和自动售货机的合法性)的显著性外,价格政策也具有边缘显著性(b(价格政策)=-0.026,P=0.050)。所有关系均呈预期方向。对于女孩,该模型的拟合效果不佳;仅在最终模型中自动售货机的合法性具有边缘显著性(b(完全禁止自动售货机)=-0.372,P=0.06)。
对于男孩来说,目前推荐的一些烟草控制政策可能有助于降低吸烟率。然而,该模型对于女孩不太适用,表明吸烟政策的潜在效果存在性别差异。未来的研究应解决这一问题。