Chalew Talia E, Halden Rolf U
Graduate Student, Center for Water and Health, Bloomberg School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, U.S.A.
J Am Water Works Assoc. 2009;45(1):4-13. doi: 10.1111/j.1752-1688.2008.00284.x.
The synthetic biocides triclosan (5-chloro-2-(2,4-dichlorophenoxy)phenol) and triclocarban (3,4,4'-trichlorocarbanilide) are routinely added to a wide array of antimicrobial personal care products and consumer articles. Both compounds can persist in the environment and exhibit toxicity toward a number of biological receptors. Recent reports of toxicological effects in wildlife, human cell cultures, and laboratory animals have heightened the interest in the occurrence of these biocide and related toxic effects. The present study aimed to summarize published environmental concentrations of biocides and contrast them with toxicity threshold values of susceptible organisms. Environmental occurrences and toxicity threshold values span more than six orders of magnitude in concentration. The highest biocide levels, measured in the mid parts-per-million range, were determined to occur in aquatic sediments and in municipal biosolids destined for land application. Crustacea and algae were identified as the most sensitive species, susceptible to adverse effects from biocide exposures in the parts-per-trillion range. An overlap of environmental concentrations and toxicity threshold values was noted for these more sensitive organisms, suggesting potential adverse ecological effects in aquatic environments. Affirmative evidence for this is lacking, however, since studies examining environmental occurrences of biocides vis-à-vis the health and diversity of aquatic species have not yet been conducted.
合成生物杀灭剂三氯生(5-氯-2-(2,4-二氯苯氧基)苯酚)和三氯卡班(3,4,4'-三氯碳酰替苯胺)通常被添加到各种各样的抗菌个人护理产品和消费品中。这两种化合物都能在环境中持续存在,并对多种生物受体表现出毒性。最近关于野生动物、人类细胞培养物和实验动物毒理学效应的报道,增加了人们对这些生物杀灭剂的存在及其相关毒性效应的关注。本研究旨在总结已发表的生物杀灭剂环境浓度,并将其与易感生物的毒性阈值进行对比。环境浓度和毒性阈值在浓度上跨越了六个多数量级。在百万分之几的范围内测得的最高生物杀灭剂水平,被确定出现在水生沉积物和用于土地施用的城市生物固体中。甲壳类动物和藻类被确定为最敏感的物种,在万亿分之几的范围内就容易受到生物杀灭剂暴露的不利影响。对于这些更敏感的生物,人们注意到环境浓度和毒性阈值存在重叠,这表明在水生环境中可能存在不利的生态影响。然而,由于尚未开展关于生物杀灭剂的环境存在情况与水生物种健康和多样性之间关系的研究,因此缺乏对此的肯定证据。