Caine N, Harrison S C, Sharples L D, Wallwork J
Department of Community Medicine, University of Cambridge.
BMJ. 1991 Mar 2;302(6775):511-6. doi: 10.1136/bmj.302.6775.511.
Measurement of changes in patients' perceptions of how differing states of health affect their lives and determination of the ability of preoperative variables to predict outcome after coronary artery bypass grafting.
Prospective study with completion of questionnaires before coronary artery bypass grafting and at three months, one year, and five years afterwards.
Regional cardiothoracic centre.
100 Male patients all aged below 60 at the time of operation, who were patients of two cardiothoracic surgeons.
Patients' assessment of their health state in terms of functional capacity and aspects of distress, according to the Nottingham health profile and outcome of operation in terms of changes in symptoms, working life, and daily activities determined by self completed study questionnaires before operation and at three and six months afterwards.
Intermediate one year results are reported. The differences between the Nottingham health profile scores before operation and at three months afterwards were significantly different (p less than 0.01), indicating an appreciable improvement in general health state, and at one year compared favourably with those from a normal male population. Analysis of responses to the study questionnaire showed that 65 of 89 patients (73%) were working at one year after operation with a further seven (8%) maintaining that they were fit to work but unable to find employment. The proportion of patients complaining of chest pain fell from 90% (88/98) before grafting to 19% (17/89) at one year after coronary artery bypass grafting, when 91% (81/89) patients maintained that their condition was either completely better or definitely improved. The significant positive factors affecting return to work and home activities were working before operation, short wait for operation, absence of breathlessness, and low physical mobility score in the Nottingham health profile (all p less than 0.001).
Improvements were evident in general health state, symptoms, and activity at three months and one year after coronary artery bypass graft surgery. Interventions likely to influence outcomes included reduction in waiting times for operation; rehabilitation initiatives; and more attention to the quality of information given to patients, their relatives, and the community.
测量患者对不同健康状态如何影响其生活的认知变化,并确定术前变量预测冠状动脉搭桥术后结果的能力。
前瞻性研究,在冠状动脉搭桥术前以及术后三个月、一年和五年完成问卷调查。
地区心胸中心。
100名男性患者,手术时年龄均在60岁以下,均为两位心胸外科医生的患者。
根据诺丁汉健康量表,患者对其功能能力和痛苦方面的健康状态进行评估,以及根据术前和术后三个月及六个月自行填写的研究问卷确定的症状、工作生活和日常活动变化来评估手术结果。
报告了一年的中期结果。术前和术后三个月的诺丁汉健康量表评分差异显著(p<0.01),表明总体健康状态有明显改善,且一年时与正常男性人群相比情况良好。对研究问卷回复的分析显示,89名患者中有65名(73%)术后一年仍在工作,另有7名(8%)表示适合工作但找不到工作。抱怨胸痛的患者比例从术前的90%(88/98)降至冠状动脉搭桥术后一年的19%(17/89),此时91%(81/89)的患者表示病情完全好转或明显改善。影响恢复工作和家庭活动的显著积极因素包括术前工作、手术等待时间短、无呼吸急促以及诺丁汉健康量表中身体活动能力得分低(均p<0.001)。
冠状动脉搭桥手术后三个月和一年,总体健康状态、症状和活动均有明显改善。可能影响结果的干预措施包括减少手术等待时间;康复计划;以及更多关注向患者、其亲属和社区提供的信息质量。