Shaw Lynn, Descarreaux Martin, Bryans Roland, Duranleau Mireille, Marcoux Henri, Potter Brock, Ruegg Rick, Watkin Robert, White Eleanor
Faculty of Health Sciences, School of Occupational Therapy, University of Western Ontario, London, ON, Canada.
Work. 2010;35(3):369-94. doi: 10.3233/WOR-2010-0996.
The literature relevant to the treatment of Whiplash-Associated Disorders (WAD) is extensive and heterogeneous.
A Participatory Action Research (PAR) approach was used to engage a chiropractic community of practice and stakeholders in a systematic review to address a general question: 'Does chiropractic management of WAD clients have an effect on improving health status?' A systematic review of the empirical studies relevant to WAD interventions was conducted followed by a review of the evidence.
The initial search identified 1,155 articles. Ninety-two of the articles were retrieved, and 27 articles consistent with specific criteria of WAD intervention were analyzed in-depth. The best evidence supporting the chiropractic management of clients with WAD is reported. Further review identified ways to overcome gaps needed to inform clinical practice and culminated in the development of a proposed care model: the WAD-Plus Model.
There is a baseline of evidence that suggests chiropractic care improves cervical range of motion (cROM) and pain in the management of WAD. However, the level of this evidence relevant to clinical practice remains low or draws on clinical consensus at this time. The WAD-Plus Model has implications for use by chiropractors and interdisciplinary professionals in the assessment and management of acute, subacute and chronic pain due to WAD. Furthermore, the WAD-Plus Model can be used in the future study of interventions and outcomes to advance evidence-based care in the management of WAD.
与挥鞭样相关疾病(WAD)治疗相关的文献广泛且繁杂。
采用参与式行动研究(PAR)方法,让整脊治疗从业者群体和利益相关者参与一项系统评价,以解决一个一般性问题:“整脊治疗对WAD患者的健康状况改善是否有效果?”对与WAD干预相关的实证研究进行了系统评价,随后对证据进行了审查。
初步检索到1155篇文章。检索出92篇文章,并对其中27篇符合WAD干预特定标准的文章进行了深入分析。报告了支持对WAD患者进行整脊治疗的最佳证据。进一步审查确定了克服为临床实践提供信息所需差距的方法,并最终形成了一个提议的护理模式:WAD加模式。
有证据表明,整脊治疗在WAD管理中可改善颈椎活动范围(cROM)和疼痛。然而,目前与临床实践相关的这一证据水平仍然较低,或基于临床共识。WAD加模式对整脊治疗师和跨学科专业人员在评估和管理WAD引起的急性、亚急性和慢性疼痛方面具有应用意义。此外,WAD加模式可用于未来干预措施和结果的研究,以推进WAD管理中的循证护理。