Division of Research, Kaiser Permanente Northern California, 2000 Broadway, Oakland, CA, USA.
BMC Cancer. 2010 May 19;10:215. doi: 10.1186/1471-2407-10-215.
Malignant glioma is a rare cancer with poor survival. The influence of diet and antioxidant intake on glioma survival is not well understood. The current study examines the association between antioxidant intake and survival after glioma diagnosis.
Adult patients diagnosed with malignant glioma during 1991-1994 and 1997-2001 were enrolled in a population-based study. Diagnosis was confirmed by review of pathology specimens. A modified food-frequency questionnaire interview was completed by each glioma patient or a designated proxy. Intake of each food item was converted to grams consumed/day. From this nutrient database, 16 antioxidants, calcium, a total antioxidant index and 3 macronutrients were available for survival analysis. Cox regression estimated mortality hazard ratios associated with each nutrient and the antioxidant index adjusting for potential confounders. Nutrient values were categorized into tertiles. Models were stratified by histology (Grades II, III, and IV) and conducted for all (including proxy) subjects and for a subset of self-reported subjects.
Geometric mean values for 11 fat-soluble and 6 water-soluble individual antioxidants, antioxidant index and 3 macronutrients were virtually the same when comparing all cases (n=748) to self-reported cases only (n=450). For patients diagnosed with Grade II and Grade III histology, moderate (915.8-2118.3 mcg) intake of fat-soluble lycopene was associated with poorer survival when compared to low intake (0.0-914.8 mcg), for self-reported cases only. High intake of vitamin E and moderate/high intake of secoisolariciresinol among Grade III patients indicated greater survival for all cases. In Grade IV patients, moderate/high intake of cryptoxanthin and high intake of secoisolariciresinol were associated with poorer survival among all cases. Among Grade II patients, moderate intake of water-soluble folate was associated with greater survival for all cases; high intake of vitamin C and genistein and the highest level of the antioxidant index were associated with poorer survival for all cases.
The associations observed in our study suggest that the influence of some antioxidants on survival following a diagnosis of malignant glioma are inconsistent and vary by histology group. Further research in a large sample of glioma patients is needed to confirm/refute our results.
恶性脑胶质瘤是一种罕见的癌症,患者生存率低。饮食和抗氧化剂摄入对脑胶质瘤患者生存率的影响尚未明确。本研究旨在探讨脑胶质瘤患者诊断后抗氧化剂摄入与生存时间的相关性。
1991-1994 年和 1997-2001 年期间,在人群中纳入诊断为恶性脑胶质瘤的成年患者。通过病理标本回顾性诊断脑胶质瘤。每位脑胶质瘤患者或指定代理人完成了改良后的食物频率问卷。根据营养素数据库,将每种食物的摄入量转换为每天消耗的克数。该数据库包含 16 种抗氧化剂、钙、总抗氧化指数和 3 种宏量营养素,可用于生存分析。Cox 回归估计了与每种营养素和抗氧化指数相关的死亡率风险比,调整了潜在混杂因素。营养素值分为三分位。按组织学(II 级、III 级和 IV 级)分层模型,并对所有(包括代理人)受试者和部分自我报告受试者进行了分析。
当比较所有病例(n=748)和仅自我报告病例(n=450)时,11 种脂溶性和 6 种水溶性单个抗氧化剂、抗氧化指数和 3 种宏量营养素的几何平均值几乎相同。对于诊断为 II 级和 III 级组织学的患者,仅自我报告病例中,脂溶性番茄红素的中等(915.8-2118.3 mcg)摄入量与低摄入量(0.0-914.8 mcg)相比,生存时间更差。III 级患者中,维生素 E 摄入量较高和贯叶连翘素中等/高摄入量表明所有病例的生存率更高。IV 级患者中,所有病例中中等/高摄入量的隐黄质和贯叶连翘素高摄入量与生存率较差相关。II 级患者中,所有病例中水溶性叶酸的中等摄入量与生存率较高相关;所有病例中维生素 C、染料木黄酮和抗氧化指数的最高水平与生存率较差相关。
本研究观察到的相关性表明,一些抗氧化剂对恶性脑胶质瘤患者生存时间的影响不一致,且因组织学分组而异。需要在更大的脑胶质瘤患者样本中进行进一步研究,以证实/反驳我们的结果。