Jain Anil K, Dhammi Ish Kumar, Jain Saurabh, Kumar Jaswant
Department of Orthopaedics, University College of Medical Sciences, University of Delhi, Delhi 110095, India.
Indian J Orthop. 2010 Oct;44(4):409-16. doi: 10.4103/0019-5413.69315.
Anterior decompression with posterior instrumentation when indicated in thoracolumbar spinal lesions if performed simultaneously in single-stage expedites rehabilitation and recovery. Transthoracic, transdiaphragmatic approach to access the thoracolumbar junction is associated with significant morbidity, as it violates thoracic cavity; requires cutting of diaphragm and a separate approach, for posterior instrumentation. We evaluated the clinical outcome morbidity and feasibility of extrapleural retroperitoneal approach to perform anterior decompression and posterior instrumentation simultaneously by single "T" incision outcome in thoracolumbar spinal trauma and tuberculosis.
Forty-eight cases of tubercular spine (n = 25) and fracture of the spine (n = 23) were included in the study of which 29 were male and 19 female. The mean age of patients was 29.1 years. All patients underwent single-stage anterior decompression, fusion, and posterior instrumentation (except two old traumatic cases) via extrapleural retroperitoneal approach by single "T" incision. Tuberculosis cases were operated in lateral position as they were stabilized with Hartshill instrumentation. For traumatic spine initially posterior pedicle screw fixation was performed in prone position and then turned to right lateral position for anterior decompression by same incision and approach. They were evaluated for blood loss, duration of surgery, superficial and deep infection of incision site, flap necrosis, correction of the kyphotic deformity, and restoration of anterior and posterior vertebral body height.
In traumatic spine group the mean duration of surgery was 269 minutes (range 215-315 minutes) including the change over time from prone to lateral position. The mean intraoperative blood loss was 918 ml (range 550-1100 ml). The preoperative mean ASIA motor, pin prick and light touch score improved from 63.3 to 74.4, 86 to 94.4 and 86 to 96 at 6 month of follow-up respectively. The mean preoperative loss of the anterior vertebral height improved from 44.7% to 18.4% immediate postoperatively and was 17.5% at final follow-up at 1 year. The means preoperative kyphus angle also improved from 23.3° to 9.3° immediately after surgery, which deteriorated to 11.5° at final follow-up. One patient developed deep wound infection at the operative site as well as flap necrosis, which needed debridement and removal of hardware. Five patients had bed sore in the sacral region, which healed uneventfully. In tubercular spine (n=25) group, mean operating time was approximately 45 minutes less than traumatic group. The mean intraoperative blood loss was 1100 ml (750-2200 ml). The mean preoperative kyphosis was corrected from 55° to 23°. Wound healing occurred uneventful in 23 cases and wound dehiscence occurred in only 2 cases. Nine out of 11 cases with paraplegia showed excellent neural recovery while 2 with panvertebral disease showed partial neural recovery. None of the patients in both groups required intensive unit care.
Simultaneous exposure of both posterior and anterior column of the spine for posterior instrumentation and anterior decompression and fusion in single stage by extra pleural retroperitoneal approach by "T" incision in thoracolumbar spinal lesions is safe, an easy alternative with reduced morbidity as chest and abdominal cavities are not violated, ICU care is not required and diaphragm is not cut.
对于胸腰椎脊柱病变,在有指征时同期进行前路减压和后路内固定可加快康复和恢复。经胸、经膈肌入路到达胸腰段交界处会带来显著的发病率,因为它侵犯胸腔;需要切开膈肌且需采用单独的入路进行后路内固定。我们评估了经胸膜外腹膜后入路通过单一“T”形切口同期进行前路减压和后路内固定在胸腰椎脊柱创伤和结核中的临床疗效、发病率及可行性。
本研究纳入了48例脊柱结核患者(n = 25)和脊柱骨折患者(n = 23),其中男性29例,女性19例。患者的平均年龄为29.1岁。所有患者均通过经胸膜外腹膜后入路经单一“T”形切口进行一期前路减压、融合及后路内固定(2例陈旧性创伤病例除外)。脊柱结核病例采用侧卧位手术,并用Hartshill器械进行固定。对于创伤性脊柱,最初在俯卧位进行后路椎弓根螺钉固定,然后转为右侧卧位,通过相同的切口和入路进行前路减压。对患者的失血量、手术时长、切口部位的浅表及深部感染、皮瓣坏死、后凸畸形的矫正以及椎体前缘和后缘高度的恢复情况进行评估。
在创伤性脊柱组,手术平均时长为269分钟(范围215 - 315分钟),包括从俯卧位转为侧卧位的时间。术中平均失血量为918毫升(范围550 - 1100毫升)。随访6个月时,术前美国脊髓损伤协会(ASIA)运动、针刺觉和轻触觉评分分别从63.3提高到74.4、从86提高到94.4以及从86提高到96。术前椎体前缘高度的平均丢失率从44.7%在术后即刻改善至18.4%,在1年的最终随访时为17.5%。术前脊柱后凸角在术后即刻也从23.3°改善至9.3°,在最终随访时恶化至11.5°。1例患者手术部位发生深部伤口感染及皮瓣坏死,需要清创和取出内固定物。5例患者骶尾部出现压疮,均顺利愈合。在脊柱结核(n = 25)组,平均手术时间比创伤组约少45分钟。术中平均失血量为1100毫升(750 - 2200毫升)。术前平均后凸畸形从55°矫正至23°。23例伤口愈合顺利,仅2例伤口裂开。11例截瘫患者中有9例神经恢复良好,2例全椎体受累患者神经部分恢复。两组患者均无需重症监护。
对于胸腰椎脊柱病变,通过经胸膜外腹膜后入路经“T”形切口一期同时显露脊柱的前后柱以进行后路内固定、前路减压和融合是安全的,是一种简便的替代方法,发病率较低,因为未侵犯胸腔和腹腔,无需重症监护,也无需切开膈肌。