Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario, Canada.
J Dairy Sci. 2010 Nov;93(11):5225-33. doi: 10.3168/jds.2010-3428.
The objectives of this observational study were to determine and compare diagnostic criteria for postpartum endometritis in dairy cows. Data generated from 1,044 Holstein cows (6 herds) enrolled in a randomized clinical trial were used. Cows were examined for endometritis at 35±3 d (exam 1) and 56±3 d (exam 2) after parturition, using endometrial cytology (cytobrush technique), vaginal discharge scoring (Metricheck device; Simcrotech, Hamilton, New Zealand), and cervical diameter measurement (transrectal palpation). Reproductive data were recorded until 200 d after parturition. Diagnostic criteria for cytological and clinical endometritis were determined based on detrimental effect on subsequent reproductive performance, using logistic regression and Cox proportional hazard models accounting for the effect of herd clustering. Comparison of diagnostic criteria was performed using endometrial cytology as reference test or by quantifying the agreement between diagnostic approaches. At exam 1, diagnostic criteria were ≥6% polymorphonuclear cells and mucopurulent or worse (purulent or foul) vaginal discharge for cytological and clinical endometritis, respectively. At exam 2, diagnostic criteria were ≥4% polymorphonuclear cells and mucopurulent or worse vaginal discharge for cytological and clinical endometritis, respectively. Cows were classified as having cytological endometritis only, clinical endometritis only, or both cytological and clinical endometritis. Prevalence at exam 1 was 13.5, 9.4, and 5.8% for cytological endometritis only, clinical endometritis only, and both cytological and clinical endometritis, respectively. The detrimental effects of cytological and clinical endometritis on reproductive performance were additive. Among cows with clinical endometritis, only 38 and 36% had cytological endometritis at exam 1 and exam 2, respectively. Combination of diagnostic criteria improved neither the accuracy for predicting cytological endometritis nor the agreement between cytological and clinical endometritis. Overall, these results suggested that cytological and clinical endometritis may represent different manifestations of reproductive tract disease. They also suggested that use of the terminology clinical endometritis may not be accurate and that purulent vaginal discharge may be more descriptive.
本观察性研究的目的是确定和比较奶牛产后子宫内膜炎的诊断标准。使用了来自参加随机临床试验的 1044 头荷斯坦奶牛(6 个牛群)的数据。产后 35±3 天(检查 1)和 56±3 天(检查 2),使用子宫内膜细胞学( cytobrush 技术)、阴道分泌物评分(Metricheck 设备;Simcrotech,汉密尔顿,新西兰)和宫颈直径测量(直肠触诊)检查子宫内膜炎。记录繁殖数据直至产后 200 天。基于对随后繁殖性能的不利影响,使用逻辑回归和 Cox 比例风险模型确定细胞学和临床子宫内膜炎的诊断标准,同时考虑到牛群聚类的影响。使用子宫内膜细胞学作为参考测试或通过量化诊断方法之间的一致性来比较诊断标准。在检查 1 时,细胞学和临床子宫内膜炎的诊断标准分别为≥6%的多形核细胞和脓性或更差(脓性或恶臭)的阴道分泌物。在检查 2 时,细胞学和临床子宫内膜炎的诊断标准分别为≥4%的多形核细胞和脓性或更差的阴道分泌物。牛被分为仅细胞学子宫内膜炎、仅临床子宫内膜炎或细胞学和临床子宫内膜炎均有。检查 1 时,仅细胞学子宫内膜炎、仅临床子宫内膜炎和细胞学和临床子宫内膜炎的患病率分别为 13.5%、9.4%和 5.8%。细胞学和临床子宫内膜炎对繁殖性能的不利影响是累加的。在有临床子宫内膜炎的牛中,只有 38%和 36%在检查 1 和检查 2 时患有细胞学子宫内膜炎。组合诊断标准既不能提高预测细胞学子宫内膜炎的准确性,也不能提高细胞学和临床子宫内膜炎之间的一致性。总体而言,这些结果表明,细胞学和临床子宫内膜炎可能代表生殖道疾病的不同表现。它们还表明,使用临床子宫内膜炎的术语可能不准确,脓性阴道分泌物可能更具描述性。