All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Urology. 2011 Mar;77(3):558-62. doi: 10.1016/j.urology.2010.07.536. Epub 2010 Dec 4.
To look into effective use of popular Internet site YouTube as an information source on kidney stone disease. Urolithiasis is among the most common urological conditions, accounting for significant morbidity, however adequate education regarding simple lifestyle modifications and early recognition of symptoms can reduce recurrence and visits to emergency department.
YouTube was searched using Keywords "nephrolithiasis"; "renal calculi"; "renal stones"; and "kidney stones" for videos uploaded containing relevant information about the disease. Only videos in English were included. Two physician viewers watched each video and classified them as useful; misleading; or personal experiences. The kappa-statistic was used to measure inter-observer variability. Total-viewership; duration; rating; days since upload; source; and information content were noted
One-hundred ninety-nine videos had relevant information about nephrolithiasis; 58.3% of the videos had useful information and 18.1% were misleading. Useful videos had 47.2% of total viewership (i.e. total no. of views) share, whereas misleading videos had 2.8%, with statistically significant difference in viewership/day and rating among useful videos vs misleading videos. Universities'channel videos provided the best overall information coverage among the useful videos (prevention = 100%, symptoms = 80%, treatments = 60%, other information = 80%). No significant difference was seen in viewership/day or rating of useful videos based on the kind of information they contained.
YouTube has a substantial amount of information on urolithiasis. Therefore, consumer-generated outlets such as YouTube have significant potential to sway individuals' attitudes both for and against the right choice. In view of this, authoritative videos by trusted sources should be posted for dissemination of reliable information.
探讨将热门互联网网站 YouTube 有效用作肾结石疾病信息来源。尿石症是最常见的泌尿科疾病之一,发病率较高,但通过适当教育患者改变简单的生活方式和早期识别症状,可降低复发率和减少急诊就诊次数。
使用“nephrolithiasis”、“renal calculi”、“renal stones”和“kidney stones”等关键词在 YouTube 上搜索有关该疾病的相关信息视频。仅纳入包含英文内容的视频。两名医师观看每个视频并将其分类为有用、误导或个人经验。使用kappa 统计量来衡量观察者间的变异性。记录总观看次数、时长、评分、上传后天数、来源和信息内容。
有 199 个视频包含有关肾结石的相关信息;58.3%的视频提供有用信息,18.1%的视频具有误导性。有用视频的总观看次数(即总观看次数)占比为 47.2%,而误导性视频仅占 2.8%,有用视频和误导性视频的观看次数/天和评分存在统计学差异。在有用视频中,大学频道的视频提供了最佳的整体信息覆盖(预防信息 100%,症状信息 80%,治疗信息 60%,其他信息 80%)。基于其包含的信息类型,有用视频的观看次数/天或评分无显著差异。
YouTube 上有大量有关尿石症的信息。因此,像 YouTube 这样的消费者生成的信息来源具有很大的潜力,可以影响个人对正确选择的态度。考虑到这一点,应发布由可信来源制作的权威视频来传播可靠信息。