Heckbert S R, Stryker W S, Coltin K L, Manson J E, Platt R
Channing Laboratory, Department of Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA.
Am J Epidemiol. 1990 Aug;132(2):336-42. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a115663.
The computerized outpatient records of the Harvard Community Health Plan, a 230,000-member health maintenance organization, were used to determine the frequency with which serum sickness is recognized in the practice setting after exposure to antibiotics. The medical records of 3,487 children who had been prescribed cefaclor or amoxicillin were searched in December 1986 for coded diagnoses of serum sickness and related conditions. Diagnoses were validated by blinded review of dictated and written office notes. There were 12 cases of serum sickness in 11,523 child-years. During this time, these children were prescribed 13,487 courses of amoxicillin, 5,597 courses of trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (TMP-SMZ), 3,553 courses of cefaclor, and 2,325 courses of penicillin V. Serum sickness was considered to be antibiotic-related if it occurred within 20 days of initiation of antibiotic therapy. Five cases were temporally associated with cefaclor, one with both amoxicillin and TMP-SMZ, four with TMP-SMZ alone, and one with penicillin V alone. One case was not associated with any antibiotic exposure. All antibiotic-related cases occurred in children under age 6 years who were treated for otitis media or streptococcal pharyngitis, and most cases began 7-11 days after initiation of antibiotic. All but one of the antibiotic-related cases occurred in children who had relatively heavy lifetime antibiotic exposure. The risk of serum sickness was significantly elevated after cefaclor compared with amoxicillin, even among the most heavily exposed children (relative risk = 14.8, p = 0.01, 95% confidence interval 2.0-352.0). Most cases prompted several physician visits, but none required hospitalization.
哈佛社区健康计划是一个拥有23万会员的健康维护组织,其计算机化门诊记录被用于确定在接触抗生素后,血清病在实际医疗环境中的确诊频率。1986年12月,对3487名曾使用头孢克洛或阿莫西林的儿童的病历进行了检索,以查找血清病及相关病症的编码诊断。通过对口述和书面病历记录进行盲法审查来验证诊断。在11523儿童人年中发现了12例血清病病例。在此期间,这些儿童共接受了13487疗程的阿莫西林、5597疗程的甲氧苄啶 - 磺胺甲恶唑(TMP - SMZ)、3553疗程的头孢克洛和2325疗程的青霉素V治疗。如果血清病发生在抗生素治疗开始后的20天内,则被认为与抗生素相关。5例与头孢克洛在时间上相关,1例与阿莫西林和TMP - SMZ均相关,4例仅与TMP - SMZ相关,1例仅与青霉素V相关。1例与任何抗生素暴露均无关。所有与抗生素相关的病例均发生在6岁以下因中耳炎或链球菌性咽炎接受治疗的儿童中,大多数病例在抗生素治疗开始后的7 - 11天出现。除1例之外,所有与抗生素相关的病例均发生在一生中抗生素暴露相对较多的儿童中。与阿莫西林相比,使用头孢克洛后血清病的风险显著升高,即使在暴露最多的儿童中也是如此(相对风险 = 14.8,p = 0.01,95%置信区间2.0 - 352.0)。大多数病例促使医生进行了多次问诊,但均无需住院治疗。