Zinkernagel R M, Althage A, Cooper S, Kreeb G, Klein P A, Sefton B, Flaherty L, Stimpfling J, Shreffler D, Klein J
J Exp Med. 1978 Aug 1;148(2):592-606. doi: 10.1084/jem.148.2.592.
H-2 dependent and virus-specific Ir genes regulate the generation of primary virus-specific K or D restricted cytotoxic T-cell responses in vivo. The following examples have been analyzed in some detail: first, Dk restricted responses to vaccinia in Sendai viruses are at least 30 times lower than the corresponding K-restricted responses irrespective of the H-2 haplotypes (k, b, d, dxs, dxq) of K and I regions; in contrast, LCMV infection generates high responses to Dk. These findings are consistent with but do not prove that this Ir gene maps to D. Second, Db restricted responses to vaccinia and Sendai viruses are high in strains possessing the Kq or KbIb, KbaIb haplotype, are very low in strains with Kk, and relatively low in mouse strains of the KdI-Ad haplotype; LCMV generates high Db restricted response in the presence of Kk. This Ir gene for the response to vaccinia and Sendai viruses maps to K since B10.BYR (KqIkdDb) is a responder and B10.A (2R) is a nonresponder (KkIkdDb). Third, virus and K or D allele specific nonresponsiveness is dominant with variable penetrance; in heterozygous mice the nonresponder Kk allele over-rides responsiveness normally found in KbDb or KqDb combinations. Fourth, when (responder X nonresponder)F1 lymphocytes are stimulated in an environment expressing vaccinia virus plus only a high responder Kb or Kq allelle and Db, response to vaccinia Db is high; in contrast when the same F1 cells are stimulated in an environment expressing the low responder allele Kk, response to vaccinia Db is low. Thus absence of Kk during immunization allows generation of high responsive Db restricted vaccinia specific cytotoxic T cells. The Dk dependent low response to vaccinia Dk can be explained by a preclusion rule or by failure of vaccinia to complex with Db; however the analysis of Kk dependent low response to vaccinia Db does not support these explanations or that self-tolerance is responsible for this Ir effect but is compatible with the interpretation that Kk vaccinia is immunodominant over Db vaccinia. These results are discussed with respect to (a) possible mechanisms of regulation by Ir genes and (b) H-2 polymorphism and HLA-disease association.
H-2依赖性和病毒特异性Ir基因在体内调节原发性病毒特异性K或D限制性细胞毒性T细胞反应的产生。以下例子已进行了较为详细的分析:首先,无论K和I区域的H-2单倍型(k、b、d、dxs、dxq)如何,仙台病毒中对痘苗病毒的Dk限制性反应比相应的K限制性反应至少低30倍;相比之下,淋巴细胞脉络丛脑膜炎病毒(LCMV)感染会产生对Dk的高反应。这些发现与之相符,但并未证明该Ir基因定位于D。其次,在具有Kq或KbIb、KbaIb单倍型的品系中,对痘苗病毒和仙台病毒的Db限制性反应较高,在具有Kk的品系中非常低,在KdI-Ad单倍型的小鼠品系中相对较低;在存在Kk的情况下,LCMV会产生高Db限制性反应。针对痘苗病毒和仙台病毒反应的这个Ir基因定位于K,因为B10.BYR(KqIkdDb)是反应者,而B10.A(2R)是非反应者(KkIkdDb)。第三,病毒和K或D等位基因特异性无反应性具有显性且外显率可变;在杂合小鼠中,无反应性的Kk等位基因会掩盖KbDb或KqDb组合中通常发现的反应性。第四,如果(反应者×非反应者)F1淋巴细胞在表达痘苗病毒且仅存在高反应性Kb或Kq等位基因以及Db的环境中受到刺激,对痘苗病毒Db的反应较高;相反,当相同的F1细胞在表达低反应性等位基因Kk的环境中受到刺激时,对痘苗病毒Db的反应较低。因此,免疫期间不存在Kk可使产生高反应性的Db限制性痘苗病毒特异性细胞毒性T细胞。对痘苗病毒Dk的Dk依赖性低反应可以用排除规则或痘苗病毒与Db无法形成复合物来解释;然而,对痘苗病毒Db的Kk依赖性低反应分析并不支持这些解释,也不支持自身耐受性是这种Ir效应的原因,但与Kk痘苗病毒比Db痘苗病毒具有免疫优势的解释相符。将结合(a)Ir基因可能的调节机制和(b)H-2多态性与HLA-疾病关联来讨论这些结果。