Department of Emergency Medicine, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL.
West J Emerg Med. 2010 Dec;11(5):491-9.
The Education in Palliative and End-of-life Care for Emergency Medicine Project (EPEC™-EM) is a comprehensive curriculum in palliative and end-of-life care for emergency providers. We assessed the adaptation of this course to an EM residency program using synchronous and asynchronous learning.
Curriculum adaptation followed Kern's standardized six-step curriculum design process. Post-graduate year (PGY) 1-4 residents were taught all EPEC™-EM cognitive domains, divided as seven synchronous and seven asynchronous modules. All synchronous modules featured large group didactic lectures and review of EPEC™-EM course materials. Asynchronous modules use only EPEC™-EM electronic course media for resident self-study. Targeted evaluation for EPEC™-EM knowledge objectives was conducted by a prospective case-control crossover study, with synchronous learning serving as the quasi-control, using validated exam tools. We compared de-identified test scores for effectiveness of learning method, using aggregate group performance means for each learning strategy.
Of 45 eligible residents 55% participated in a pre-test for local needs analysis, and 78% completed a post-test to measure teaching method effect. Post-test scores improved across all EPEC™-EM domains, with a mean improvement for synchronous modules of +28% (SD=9) and a mean improvement for asynchronous modules of +30% (SD=18). The aggregate mean difference between learning methods was 1.9% (95% CI -15.3, +19.0). Mean test scores of the residents who completed the post-test were: synchronous modules 77% (SD=12); asynchronous modules 83% (SD=13); all modules 80% (SD=12).
EPEC™-EM adapted materials can improve resident knowledge of palliative medicine domains, as assessed through validated testing of course objectives. Synchronous and asynchronous learning methods appear to result in similar knowledge transfer, feasibly allowing some course content to be effectively delivered outside of large group lectures.
急诊医学中的缓和医疗和临终关怀教育项目(EPEC™-EM)是一门针对急诊提供者的缓和医疗和临终关怀综合课程。我们使用同步和异步学习来评估该课程在急诊住院医师培训计划中的适应性。
课程改编遵循 Kern 的标准化六步课程设计流程。PGY1-4 住院医师教授所有 EPEC™-EM 认知领域,分为七个同步模块和七个异步模块。所有同步模块都采用大组讲授和复习 EPEC™-EM 课程材料。异步模块仅使用 EPEC™-EM 电子课程媒体供住院医师自学。采用前瞻性病例对照交叉研究对 EPEC™-EM 知识目标进行针对性评估,同步学习作为准对照,使用经过验证的考试工具。我们比较了每种学习策略的学习方法效果的测试分数,使用每个学习策略的总体组表现平均值。
在 45 名符合条件的住院医师中,有 55%参加了本地需求分析的预测试,有 78%完成了测试教学方法效果的后测。所有 EPEC™-EM 领域的后测分数均有所提高,同步模块的平均提高幅度为+28%(SD=9),异步模块的平均提高幅度为+30%(SD=18)。学习方法之间的总体平均差异为 1.9%(95%CI-15.3,+19.0)。完成后测的住院医师的平均测试分数为:同步模块 77%(SD=12);异步模块 83%(SD=13);所有模块 80%(SD=12)。
EPEC™-EM 改编材料可以通过对课程目标进行验证性测试来提高住院医师对姑息医学领域的知识,同步和异步学习方法似乎可以实现类似的知识转移,有可能使一些课程内容在不进行大组讲座的情况下有效地进行教学。