Park C L, Roberts D E, Aldington D J, Moore R A
ST4 in Anaesthetics & Intensive Care Medicine, St Georges Hospital, London, UK.
J R Army Med Corps. 2010 Dec;156(4 Suppl 1):295-300. doi: 10.1136/jramc-156-04s-05.
The purpose of this systematic review is to investigate current evidence for analgesic use in the prehospital environment using expert military and civilian opinion to determine the important clinical questions. There was a high degree of agreement that pain should be no worse than mild, that pain relief be rapid (within 10 minutes), that patients should respond to verbal stimuli and not require ventilatory support, and that major adverse events should be avoided. Twenty-one studies provided information about 6212 patients; the majority reported most of the outcomes of interest. With opioids 60-70% of patients still had pain levels above 30/100 mm on a Visual Analogue Scale after 10 minutes, falling to about 30% by 30-40 minutes. Fascia iliaca blocks demonstrated some efficacy for femoral fractures. No patient on opioids required ventilatory support; two required naloxone; sedation was rare. Cardiovascular instability was uncommon. Main adverse events were dizziness or giddiness, and pruritus with opioids. There was little evidence regarding the prehospital use ofketamine.
本系统评价的目的是利用军事和民用领域的专家意见,调查目前院前环境中使用镇痛药的证据,以确定重要的临床问题。人们高度一致认为,疼痛不应超过轻度,疼痛缓解应迅速(10分钟内),患者应能对言语刺激做出反应且无需通气支持,并且应避免重大不良事件。21项研究提供了有关6212名患者的信息;大多数研究报告了大多数感兴趣的结果。使用阿片类药物时,60%-70%的患者在10分钟后视觉模拟量表上的疼痛水平仍高于30/100mm,到30-40分钟时降至约30%。髂筋膜阻滞对股骨骨折显示出一定疗效。使用阿片类药物的患者均无需通气支持;2名患者需要纳洛酮;镇静很少见。心血管不稳定并不常见。主要不良事件是头晕或眩晕,以及使用阿片类药物时出现瘙痒。关于院前使用氯胺酮的证据很少。