School of Civil Engineering and the Environment, University of Southampton, Lanchester Building, University Rd., Highfield, Southampton, Hampshire SO17 1BJ, UK.
Waste Manag. 2011 Jul;31(7):1617-34. doi: 10.1016/j.wasman.2011.01.031. Epub 2011 Mar 3.
Mobile phones have relatively short lifecycles and are rapidly seen as obsolete by many users within little over a year. However, the reusability of these devices as well as their material composition means that in terms of mass and volume, mobile phones represent the most valuable electronic products that are currently found in large numbers in waste streams. End-of-life mobile phones are a high value (from a reuse and resource perspective), high volume (quantity), low cost (residual monetary value) and transient (short lifecycle) electronic product. There are very large numbers of higher education (mainly university) students in the world--there are>2.4 million in the UK alone, 19 million in Europe and 18.2 million in the USA--and they often replace their mobile phones several times before graduation. Thus, because of the potentially significant environmental and economic impacts, a large scale survey of students at 5 UK universities was conducted to assess the behaviour of students with regard to their use and disposal of mobile phones. Additionally, a small scale trial mobile phone takeback service at one of the universities was carried out. The findings indicate that many students replace their phones at least once a year; replacing broken phones, getting upgrades from network operators, remaining "fashionable" and a desire to have a handset with a longer battery life are the main reasons for such rapid replacement. Almost 60% of replaced phones are not sent to reuse or recycling operations but are stockpiled by students mainly as spare/backup phones. Approximately 61% of students own an extra mobile phone with male students replacing their phones more often than females. In particular, the results highlight the potentially huge stockpile of mobile phones--and consequently valuable supplies of rare metals--being held by the public; we estimate that there are 3.7 million phones stockpiled by students in UK higher education alone (29.3 and 28.1 million stockpiled, respectively, for Europe and USA). Although many students are aware of UK mobile phone takeback services, only a moderate number have previously used the services. Students' recycling of other waste materials such as paper and glass did not have a significant impact on their disposal actions for their unwanted mobile phones, although students who often recycled these waste materials were also the most willing to participate in mobile phone takeback services. Monetary incentives such as cash payments and vouchers have the greatest influence over students' willingness to utilise takeback services, followed by convenience and ease of use of the services. The paper discusses these findings as well as the outcome of the trial mobile phone takeback. It is suggested that universities should partner with established takeback operators to conduct event-based mobile phone takeback services primarily targeting students. Lessons from mobile phone takeback applicable to takeback services for end-of-life gadgets similar to mobile phones are also discussed.
手机的生命周期相对较短,许多用户在不到一年的时间内就认为它们已经过时。然而,这些设备的可重复使用性以及它们的材料组成意味着,就质量和体积而言,手机是目前在废物中数量最多的最有价值的电子产品。废旧手机是一种高价值(从再利用和资源角度来看)、高数量(数量)、低成本(剩余货币价值)和短暂(生命周期短)的电子产品。全球有大量的高等教育(主要是大学)学生——仅英国就有超过 240 万学生,欧洲有 1900 万学生,美国有 1820 万学生——他们在毕业前通常会更换几次手机。因此,由于潜在的重大环境和经济影响,对 5 所英国大学的学生进行了大规模调查,以评估学生对手机使用和处置的行为。此外,在其中一所大学进行了小规模的手机回收试点服务。调查结果表明,许多学生每年至少更换一次手机;更换坏手机、从网络运营商处获得升级、保持“时尚”以及希望拥有电池寿命更长的手机是这种快速更换的主要原因。几乎 60%的废旧手机没有被送往再利用或回收处理,而是被学生囤积起来,主要作为备用/备份手机。大约 61%的学生拥有一部额外的手机,男生比女生更频繁地更换手机。特别是,调查结果突出显示了公众手中可能大量囤积的手机——以及由此产生的有价值的稀有金属供应——我们估计,仅英国高等教育系统中就有 370 万部手机被学生囤积(分别为欧洲和美国的 2930 万部和 2810 万部)。尽管许多学生都知道英国的手机回收服务,但只有少数人之前曾使用过这些服务。尽管经常回收这些废物的学生也最愿意参与手机回收服务,但学生对其他废物材料(如纸张和玻璃)的回收并没有对他们处理不需要的手机的行为产生重大影响。金钱奖励,如现金支付和代金券,对学生使用回收服务的意愿影响最大,其次是服务的便利性和易用性。本文讨论了这些发现以及试点手机回收的结果。本文建议大学应与成熟的回收运营商合作,主要针对学生开展基于活动的手机回收服务。还讨论了适用于类似手机的报废小工具的回收服务的手机回收经验教训。