Long Nanye, Gianola Daniel, Rosa Guilherme J M, Weigel Kent A
Department of Animal Sciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1675 Observatory Dr. Animal Science Bldg, Madison, WI 53706, USA.
Genetica. 2011 Jul;139(7):843-54. doi: 10.1007/s10709-011-9588-7. Epub 2011 Jun 15.
It has become increasingly clear from systems biology arguments that interaction and non-linearity play an important role in genetic regulation of phenotypic variation for complex traits. Marker-assisted prediction of genetic values assuming additive gene action has been widely investigated because of its relevance in artificial selection. On the other hand, it has been less well-studied when non-additive effects hold. Here, we explored a nonparametric model, radial basis function (RBF) regression, for predicting quantitative traits under different gene action modes (additivity, dominance and epistasis). Using simulation, it was found that RBF had better ability (higher predictive correlations and lower predictive mean square errors) of predicting merit of individuals in future generations in the presence of non-additive effects than a linear additive model, the Bayesian Lasso. This was true for populations undergoing either directional or random selection over several generations. Under additive gene action, RBF was slightly worse than the Bayesian Lasso. While prediction of genetic values under additive gene action is well handled by a variety of parametric models, nonparametric RBF regression is a useful counterpart for dealing with situations where non-additive gene action is suspected, and it is robust irrespective of mode of gene action.
从系统生物学的观点来看,越来越清楚的是,相互作用和非线性在复杂性状表型变异的遗传调控中起着重要作用。由于其在人工选择中的相关性,假设加性基因作用的遗传值的标记辅助预测已得到广泛研究。另一方面,当非加性效应存在时,相关研究较少。在此,我们探索了一种非参数模型——径向基函数(RBF)回归,用于预测不同基因作用模式(加性、显性和上位性)下的数量性状。通过模拟发现,在存在非加性效应的情况下,与线性加性模型贝叶斯套索相比,RBF在预测后代个体优良度方面具有更好的能力(更高的预测相关性和更低的预测均方误差)。对于经历了几代定向或随机选择的群体来说都是如此。在加性基因作用下,RBF比贝叶斯套索稍差。虽然加性基因作用下的遗传值预测可以通过多种参数模型很好地处理,但非参数RBF回归是处理怀疑存在非加性基因作用情况的有用对应方法,并且无论基因作用模式如何,它都具有稳健性。