Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, P,O, Box, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland.
Parasit Vectors. 2011 Jul 20;4:142. doi: 10.1186/1756-3305-4-142.
Reliable maps of the geographical distribution, number of infected individuals and burden estimates of schistosomiasis are essential tools to plan, monitor and evaluate control programmes. Large-scale disease mapping and prediction efforts rely on compiled historical survey data obtained from the peer-reviewed literature and unpublished reports. Schistosomiasis surveys usually focus on school-aged children, whereas some surveys include entire communities. However, data are often reported for non-standard age groups or entire study populations. Existing geostatistical models ignore either the age-dependence of the disease risk or omit surveys considered too heterogeneous.
We developed Bayesian geostatistical models and analysed existing schistosomiasis prevalence data by estimating alignment factors to relate surveys on individuals aged ≤ 20 years with surveys on individuals aged > 20 years and entire communities. Schistosomiasis prevalence data for 11 countries in the eastern African region were extracted from an open-access global database pertaining to neglected tropical diseases. We assumed that alignment factors were constant for the whole region or a specific country.
Regional alignment factors indicated that the risk of a Schistosoma haematobium infection in individuals aged > 20 years and in entire communities is smaller than in individuals ≤ 20 years, 0.83 and 0.91, respectively. Country-specific alignment factors varied from 0.79 (Ethiopia) to 1.06 (Zambia) for community-based surveys. For S. mansoni, the regional alignment factor for entire communities was 0.96 with country-specific factors ranging from 0.84 (Burundi) to 1.13 (Uganda).
The proposed approach could be used to align inherent age-heterogeneity between school-based and community-based schistosomiasis surveys to render compiled data for risk mapping and prediction more accurate.
可靠的地理分布地图、感染人数和血吸虫病负担估计,是规划、监测和评估控制规划的重要工具。大规模疾病测绘和预测工作依赖于从同行评议文献和未发表报告中汇编的历史调查数据。血吸虫病调查通常集中在学龄儿童,但有些调查包括整个社区。然而,数据通常是按非标准年龄组或整个研究人群报告的。现有的地质统计学模型忽略了疾病风险的年龄依赖性,或者忽略了认为过于异质的调查。
我们开发了贝叶斯地质统计学模型,并通过估计关联因子来分析现有的血吸虫病流行率数据,以将 20 岁以下个体的调查与 20 岁以上个体和整个社区的调查相关联。从一个关于被忽视热带病的公开获取的全球数据库中提取了东非 11 个国家的血吸虫病流行率数据。我们假设关联因子在整个区域或特定国家都是恒定的。
区域关联因子表明,20 岁以上个体和整个社区中感染曼氏血吸虫的风险小于 20 岁以下个体,分别为 0.83 和 0.91。基于社区的调查,国家特定的关联因子从埃塞俄比亚的 0.79 到赞比亚的 1.06 不等。对于曼氏血吸虫,整个社区的区域关联因子为 0.96,国家特定的关联因子从布隆迪的 0.84 到乌干达的 1.13 不等。
所提出的方法可用于调整基于学校和基于社区的血吸虫病调查之间固有的年龄异质性,使编译的数据更准确地用于风险测绘和预测。