Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud University Nijmegen Nijmegen, Netherlands.
Front Psychol. 2011 Jun 3;2:116. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2011.00116. eCollection 2011.
Do people use sensori-motor cortices to understand language? Here we review neurocognitive studies of language comprehension in healthy adults and evaluate their possible contributions to theories of language in the brain. We start by sketching the minimal predictions that an embodied theory of language understanding makes for empirical research, and then survey studies that have been offered as evidence for embodied semantic representations. We explore four debated issues: first, does activation of sensori-motor cortices during action language understanding imply that action semantics relies on mirror neurons? Second, what is the evidence that activity in sensori-motor cortices plays a functional role in understanding language? Third, to what extent do responses in perceptual and motor areas depend on the linguistic and extra-linguistic context? And finally, can embodied theories accommodate language about abstract concepts? Based on the available evidence, we conclude that sensori-motor cortices are activated during a variety of language comprehension tasks, for both concrete and abstract language. Yet, this activity depends on the context in which perception and action words are encountered. Although modality-specific cortical activity is not a sine qua non of language processing even for language about perception and action, sensori-motor regions of the brain appear to make functional contributions to the construction of meaning, and should therefore be incorporated into models of the neurocognitive architecture of language.
人们是否使用感觉运动皮层来理解语言?在这里,我们回顾了健康成年人语言理解的神经认知研究,并评估了它们对大脑语言理论的可能贡献。我们首先概述了语言理解的具身理论对实证研究的最小预测,然后调查了被认为是具身语义表示的证据的研究。我们探讨了四个有争议的问题:第一,在动作语言理解过程中感觉运动皮层的激活是否意味着动作语义依赖于镜像神经元?第二,感觉运动皮层活动在理解语言方面发挥功能作用的证据是什么?第三,感觉和运动区域的反应在多大程度上取决于语言和非语言语境?最后,具身理论能否容纳关于抽象概念的语言?基于现有证据,我们的结论是,感觉运动皮层在各种语言理解任务中被激活,无论是具体语言还是抽象语言。然而,这种活动取决于感知和动作词所处的语境。尽管对于关于感知和动作的语言来说,特定于模态的皮层活动不是语言处理的必要条件,但大脑的感觉运动区域似乎对意义的构建做出了功能贡献,因此应该被纳入语言的神经认知结构模型。