Columbia University School of Social Work and Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, New York, USA.
Depress Anxiety. 2011 Aug;28(8):648-57. doi: 10.1002/da.20865.
Although losses are important consequences of disasters, few epidemiological studies of disasters have assessed complicated grief (CG) and none assessed CG associated with losses other than death of loved one.
Data come from the baseline survey of the Hurricane Katrina Community Advisory Group, a representative sample of 3,088 residents of the areas directly affected by Hurricane Katrina. A brief screen for CG was included containing four items consistent with the proposed DSM-V criteria for a diagnosis of bereavement-related adjustment disorder.
Fifty-eight and half percent of respondents reported a significant hurricane-related loss: Most-severe losses were 29.0% tangible, 9.5% interpersonal, 8.1% intangible, 4.2% work/financial, and 3.7% death of loved one. Twenty-six point one percent respondents with significant loss had possible CG and 7.0% moderate-to-severe CG. Death of loved one was associated with the highest conditional probability of moderate-to-severe CG (18.5%, compared to 1.1-10.5% conditional probabilities for other losses), but accounted for only 16.5% of moderate-to-severe CG due to its comparatively low prevalence. Most moderate-to-severe CG was due to tangible (52.9%) or interpersonal (24.0%) losses. Significant predictors of CG were mostly unique to either bereavement (racial-ethnic minority status, social support) or other losses (prehurricane history of psychopathology, social competence.).
Nonbereavement losses accounted for the vast majority of hurricane-related possible CG despite risk of CG being much higher in response to bereavement than to other losses. This result argues for expansion of research on CG beyond bereavement and alerts clinicians to the need to address postdisaster grief associated with a wide range of losses.
尽管损失是灾害的重要后果,但很少有灾害的流行病学研究评估过复杂悲伤(CG),也没有研究评估过除亲人死亡以外的其他损失所导致的 CG。
数据来自卡特里娜飓风社区咨询小组的基线调查,这是一个受卡特里娜飓风直接影响的地区的 3088 名居民的代表性样本。调查中包含一个简短的 CG 筛查,其中包含四个与 DSM-V 中丧亲相关适应障碍诊断标准一致的项目。
58.5%的受访者报告了与飓风相关的重大损失:最严重的损失分别是 29.0%的有形损失、9.5%的人际关系损失、8.1%的无形损失、4.2%的工作/财务损失和 3.7%的亲人死亡。26.1%有重大损失的受访者可能患有 CG,7.0%患有中度至重度 CG。亲人死亡与中度至重度 CG 的最高条件概率相关(18.5%,而其他损失的条件概率为 1.1%-10.5%),但由于其相对较低的患病率,仅占中度至重度 CG 的 16.5%。大多数中度至重度 CG 是由有形(52.9%)或人际关系(24.0%)损失引起的。CG 的显著预测因素大多是丧亲(种族少数民族地位、社会支持)或其他损失(飓风前精神病史、社会能力)所特有的。
尽管丧亲导致 CG 的风险远高于其他损失,但非丧亲损失却导致了绝大多数与飓风相关的可能 CG。这一结果表明,需要将 CG 的研究范围扩大到丧亲之外,并提醒临床医生注意需要解决与广泛损失相关的灾后悲伤问题。