Klement Andreas, Bretschneider Kristin, Lautenschläger Christine, Stang Andreas, Herrmann Markus, Haerting Johannes
Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg, Sektion Allgemeinmedizin, Halle/Saale, Deutschland.
GMS Z Med Ausbild. 2011;28(1):Doc17. doi: 10.3205/zma000729. Epub 2011 Feb 4.
The interdisciplinary topic "prevention and health promotion" (Q10) was introduced into the medical training in Germany by the new medical licensing regulations in 2004. For the conception of an effective curriculum, it is helpful to know student preferences concerning teaching-formats, attitudes and self-estimated previous knowledge. Little is known concerning student perception of "prevention and health promotion" in Germany. Thus, this explorative cross-sectional study aims to provide a first step for closing this gap.
Medical students (n=220) in the fifth academic year were asked to fill in a standardized questionnaire prior to the Q10 curriculum. Questions focused on preferences for teaching and testing formats and self-estimated previous knowledge as well as on rating the importance of prevention topics and health risks. The questions were multiple choice, five-point Likert scales and open-ended questions.
A total of 94 students filled questionnaires (42% response rate). Prevention and health promotion was rated as "important" or "very important" for their "own medical professionalism" by 68% of students. Ratings showed preferences for self-directed teaching and learning strategies, including case-based learning, and 78% wished for predominantly oral examinations. The self-estimated knowledge about prevention and health promotion is rated as "rather poor". The most favored training aim was "decision making within the physician-patient-relationship". Regarding medical health consultation, students frequently estimate "lifestyle factors" and "psychological disease" as being "very important".
Students' self-estimated poor previous knowledge of prevention and health promotion creates special challenges for curriculum development. High ratings of relevance assigned to prevention-related topics point to a motivational potential which should be utilized through suitable selection of teaching and testing formats to achieve effective and practice-relevant instructional content.
“预防与健康促进”(Q10)这一跨学科主题于2004年通过新的医学执照法规被引入德国的医学培训中。对于设计有效的课程而言,了解学生在教学形式、态度和自我评估的既往知识方面的偏好是有帮助的。在德国,关于学生对“预防与健康促进”的认知了解甚少。因此,这项探索性横断面研究旨在为填补这一空白迈出第一步。
在Q10课程开始前,要求220名五年级医学生填写一份标准化问卷。问题集中在对教学和测试形式的偏好、自我评估的既往知识,以及对预防主题和健康风险重要性的评分。问题包括多项选择题、五点李克特量表题和开放式问题。
共有94名学生填写了问卷(回复率为42%)。68%的学生认为预防与健康促进对他们“自身的医学专业素养”“重要”或“非常重要”。评分显示学生偏好自主教学和学习策略,包括基于案例的学习,78%的学生希望主要采用口试。学生对预防与健康促进的自我评估知识被评为“相当差”。最受欢迎的培训目标是“医患关系中的决策”。关于医疗健康咨询,学生经常认为“生活方式因素”和“心理疾病”“非常重要”。
学生对预防与健康促进既往知识的自我评估较差,这给课程开发带来了特殊挑战。对与预防相关主题的高度相关性评分表明存在一种激励潜力,应通过适当选择教学和测试形式来利用这种潜力,以实现有效且与实践相关的教学内容。