Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio 45267-0528, USA.
J Voice. 2012 Jul;26(4):447-53. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2011.05.006. Epub 2011 Aug 12.
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESES: There are many documented barriers to successful adherence to voice therapy. However, methods for facilitating adherence are not well understood. The purpose of this study was to determine if patient adherence and motivation for practice could be improved by providing patients with practice support between sessions using mobile treatment videos.
Thirteen voice therapy participants were provided with portable media players containing videos of voice exercises exemplified by their therapists and themselves. A randomized crossover design of two conditions was used: (1) standard of care voice therapy where participants were provided with written homework descriptions; and (2) video-enhanced voice therapy where participants received a portable digital media player with clinician and self-videos. The duration of each condition was 1 week. Self-report measures of practice frequency and aspects of motivation were obtained at the end of each session.
Practice of voice exercises was significantly greater in the video-enhanced voice therapy condition than in the standard of care "written" condition (P<0.05). Three aspects of participant motivation for practice-overall commitment to practice, importance of practice, and confidence in the ability to practice were also significantly greater after video-enhanced condition than after standard of care condition.
These results support the use of video examples and portable digital media players in voice therapy for individuals who are comfortable using such technology.
目的/假设:有许多有文献记载的障碍会阻碍成功进行嗓音治疗。然而,促进依从性的方法还不是很清楚。本研究的目的是确定通过在治疗期间提供移动治疗视频来为患者提供练习支持,是否可以提高患者的依从性和练习积极性。
为 13 名嗓音治疗参与者提供了便携式媒体播放器,其中包含了他们的治疗师和他们自己示范的嗓音练习视频。使用了两种条件的随机交叉设计:(1)标准的嗓音治疗护理,参与者获得书面作业描述;(2)视频增强的嗓音治疗,参与者收到带有临床医生和自我视频的便携式数字媒体播放器。每种条件的持续时间为 1 周。在每次治疗结束时,通过自我报告的练习频率和动机方面的测量来获取数据。
视频增强的嗓音治疗条件下的嗓音练习明显多于标准护理的“书面”条件(P<0.05)。练习的总体承诺、练习的重要性以及对练习能力的信心等三个方面的练习动机在视频增强条件下也明显高于标准护理条件下。
这些结果支持在那些使用此类技术感到舒适的个体的嗓音治疗中使用视频示例和便携式数字媒体播放器。