Brain Imaging and Analysis Center, Duke University, Durham, NC 27710, USA.
Neuroimage. 2012 Aug 15;62(2):1152-6. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.08.113. Epub 2011 Sep 22.
A primary advantage of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) over other techniques in neuroscience is its flexibility. Researchers have used fMRI to study a remarkable diversity of topics, from basic processes of perception and memory, to the complex mechanisms of economic decision making and moral cognition. The chief contributor to this experimental flexibility-indeed, to the growth of fMRI itself-has been the development of event-related experimental designs and associated analyses. The core idea of an event-related design, as first articulated in the late 1990s, is the separation of cognitive processes into discrete points in time (i.e., "events") allowing differentiation of their associated fMRI signals. By modeling brain function as a series of transient changes, rather than as an ongoing state, event-related fMRI allowed researchers to create much more complex paradigms and more dynamic analysis methods. Yet, this flexibility came with a cost. As the complexity of experimental designs increased, fMRI analyses became increasingly abstracted from the original data, which in turn has had consequences both positive (e.g., greater use of model-based fMRI) and negative (e.g., fewer articles plot the timing of activation). And, as event-related methods have become ubiquitous, they no longer represent a distinct category of fMRI research. In a real sense, event-related fMRI has now become, simply, fMRI.
功能磁共振成像(fMRI)在神经科学领域相较于其他技术的一个主要优势在于其灵活性。研究人员已经使用 fMRI 研究了从感知和记忆的基本过程到经济决策和道德认知的复杂机制等各种不同的主题。这种实验灵活性的主要促成因素——实际上也是 fMRI 本身发展的主要因素——是事件相关实验设计及其相关分析的发展。事件相关设计的核心思想,如在 20 世纪 90 年代末首次阐明的那样,是将认知过程分为离散的时间点(即“事件”),从而可以区分它们相关的 fMRI 信号。通过将大脑功能建模为一系列瞬态变化,而不是持续状态,事件相关 fMRI 允许研究人员创建更复杂的范式和更动态的分析方法。然而,这种灵活性是有代价的。随着实验设计的复杂性增加,fMRI 分析越来越脱离原始数据,这反过来又产生了积极的(例如,更多地使用基于模型的 fMRI)和消极的(例如,更少的文章绘制激活的时间)后果。而且,随着事件相关方法变得无处不在,它们不再代表 fMRI 研究的一个独特类别。从某种意义上说,事件相关 fMRI 现在已经成为简单的 fMRI。