Esquerrà Marià, Roura Poch Pere, Masat Ticó Teresa, Canal Vicenç, Maideu Mir Joaquim, Cruxent Rafael
Atención Primaria, Instituto Catalán de la Salud, Vic, Barcelona, España.
Aten Primaria. 2012 Oct;44(10):576-83. doi: 10.1016/j.aprim.2011.07.016. Epub 2011 Oct 22.
To assess the impact of training two general practitioners (GPs), on performing low complexity ultrasound examinations of the abdomen with diagnostic competence.
A non-randomised, prospective, double blind evaluation study of the acquired competence. Ultrasound examinations were performed successively and independently by the GP and the radiologist, and registered on two sheets of an identical case report form.
Departments of Vic General Hospital and Vic Health Care Centre of the Catalan Health Institute.
A total of 120 patients who needed a low complexity abdominal ultrasound from a total amount of 868 ultrasound examinations scheduled.
The kappa index of the primary diagnosis (ultrasound diagnostic conclusion), as well as of the ultrasound findings for each abdominal organ was calculated. A good level of training was considered if a minimum kappa index of 0.80 was attained between general practitioner and radiologist.
After six month running, an "ad interim" analysis showed a kappa index for the primary ultrasound diagnosis of 0.85. At the end of the study, an overall kappa index of 0.89 (95% CI: 0.82-0.98) was achieved. The agreement by organs was also high (pancreas and spleen excluded), as well as sensitivity (>75%) and specificity (>90%).
The results of the study demonstrate the feasibility of the performance, by trained GPs, of ultrasound examinations of low complexity of the abdomen with diagnostic competence.
评估培训两名全科医生(GP)进行低复杂度腹部超声检查并具备诊断能力的影响。
一项关于所获能力的非随机、前瞻性、双盲评估研究。超声检查由全科医生和放射科医生依次独立进行,并记录在同一份病例报告表的两张纸上。
加泰罗尼亚卫生研究所维克总医院和维克医疗中心。
在总共安排的868例超声检查中,共有120例需要进行低复杂度腹部超声检查的患者。
计算主要诊断(超声诊断结论)以及每个腹部器官超声检查结果的kappa指数。如果全科医生和放射科医生之间的kappa指数达到最低0.80,则认为培训水平良好。
经过六个月的运行,“中期”分析显示超声主要诊断的kappa指数为0.85。在研究结束时,总体kappa指数达到0.89(95%可信区间:0.82 - 0.98)。各器官的一致性也很高(胰腺和脾脏除外),敏感性(>75%)和特异性(>90%)也很高。
研究结果表明,经过培训的全科医生有能力进行低复杂度的腹部超声检查并具备诊断能力。