Department of Psychiatry, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
Matern Child Health J. 2013 Feb;17(2):292-8. doi: 10.1007/s10995-012-0973-3.
Access to health care for undocumented migrant children and pregnant women confronts human rights and professional values with political and institutional regulations that limit services. In order to understand how health care professionals deal with these diverging mandates, we assessed their attitudes toward providing care to this population. Clinicians, administrators, and support staff (n = 1,048) in hospitals and primary care centers of a large multiethnic city responded to an online survey about attitudes toward access to health care services. Analysis examined the role of personal and institutional correlates of these attitudes. Foreign-born respondents and those in primary care centers were more likely to assess the present access to care as a serious problem, and to endorse broad or full access to services, primarily based on human rights reasons. Clinicians were more likely than support staff to endorse full or broad access to health care services. Respondents who approved of restricted or no access also endorsed health as a basic human right (61.1%) and child development as a priority (68.6%). A wide gap separates attitudes toward entitlement to health care and the endorsement of principles stemming from human rights and the best interest of the child. Case-based discussions with professionals facing value dilemmas and training on children's rights are needed to promote equitable practices and advocacy against regulations limiting services.
无证移民儿童和孕妇获得医疗保健的机会面临着人权和专业价值观与限制服务的政治和机构法规之间的冲突。为了了解医疗保健专业人员如何应对这些相互冲突的任务,我们评估了他们对为这一人群提供护理的态度。在一个多民族大城市的医院和初级保健中心,临床医生、管理人员和支持人员(n=1048)对一项关于获得医疗保健服务的态度的在线调查做出了回应。分析考察了这些态度的个人和机构相关因素的作用。出生在国外的受访者和在初级保健中心工作的受访者更有可能将目前的医疗保健获取情况评估为严重问题,并基于人权原因支持广泛或全面的服务获取。临床医生比支持人员更有可能支持全面或广泛的医疗保健服务获取。那些赞成限制或不提供医疗保健服务的受访者也赞成健康是一项基本人权(61.1%)和儿童发展是优先事项(68.6%)。对获得医疗保健的权利的态度与基于人权和儿童最佳利益的原则的认可之间存在很大差距。需要与面临价值观困境的专业人员进行基于案例的讨论,并对儿童权利进行培训,以促进公平实践和倡导反对限制服务的法规。