Palmer D C
Anal Verbal Behav. 1998;15:3-16. doi: 10.1007/BF03392920.
Regularities in word order not specifically addressed by Skinner require behavioral interpretation if our field is to become more influential among students of language. Three such phenomena are briefly described in traditional structural terms and are offered as test cases: subtle differences in dative verbs, transformational traces, and the formation of compound nouns. It is argued that the variables that control such regularities derive from the speaker's repertoire as listener. Intraverbal frames are established as verbal responses in the listener through reinforcement by parity. Transitions from element to element in such frames are controlled, moment to moment in time, partly by the speaker's responses as a listener to his or her own verbal behavior. Although this account offers only a tentative interpretation of grammar and syntax in a limited domain, it suggests that the conceptual tools of behavior analysis are adequate to the task of explaining even the most subtle of grammatical rules.
如果我们这个领域想要在语言学习者中更具影响力,那么斯金纳未专门探讨的词序规律就需要从行为学角度进行阐释。这里用传统结构术语简要描述三种此类现象,并将其作为测试案例:与格动词的细微差别、转换痕迹以及复合名词的形成。有人认为,控制此类规律的变量源自说话者作为听者的行为储备。通过对等强化,听者内部言语框架被确立为言语反应。在这样的框架中,元素之间的转换在每时每刻都部分地由说话者作为听者对其自身言语行为的反应所控制。尽管这种解释仅对有限领域内的语法和句法提供了一种初步阐释,但它表明行为分析的概念工具足以胜任解释哪怕是最细微语法规则的任务。