Department of Radiology, King's College Hospital, London, UK.
Br J Radiol. 2012 Oct;85(1018):e858-63. doi: 10.1259/bjr/74797353. Epub 2012 Jul 4.
To assess the inter- and intra-observer variability of acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) quantification in liver segments with influence of age, body mass index (BMI) and liver capsule-to-box (CB) distance.
10 healthy volunteers were examined twice, by three experienced operators, separated by a 1-week interval. 10 readings were obtained, from segments 3, 5/6 and 7/8. Age, BMI and the CB distance were noted. The Cronbach α statistic for analysis of reliability was performed for the inter- and intra-observer studies. Multivariate linear regression models determined significance of the other parameters.
1800 velocity measurements were recorded. Mean values±standard deviation: segment 3, 1.31±0.19 m s(-1); segment 5/6, 1.12±0.22 m s(-1); segment 7/8, 1.12±0.17 m s(-1). For both the inter- and intra-observer study, the Cronbach α statistic was ≥0.7 (reliable) when taken from segments 5/6 and 7/8 but <0.7 (unreliable) for segment 3. BMI and age showed significant (p<0.0001) but contrasting correlation (segment 5/6: BMI r=0.02, age r=-0.02; segment 7/8: BMI r=-0.01, age r=0.01) with ARFI velocities when analysed for the segments deemed reliable. A weak negative correlation between ARFI velocities and liver CB distance was demonstrated for both assessed segments (segment 5/6, r=-0.08; segment 7/8, r=-0.06; p<0.001).
With trained operators, ARFI is a reliable and reproducible method of liver stiffness quantification in segments 5/6 and 7/8 but acquisition of measurements from segment 3 should be avoided. Values obtained deeper to the liver capsule allow more reliable liver stiffness quantification.
评估声辐射力脉冲(ARFI)定量在受年龄、体重指数(BMI)和肝包膜-箱(CB)距离影响的肝段中的观察者间和观察者内变异性。
10 名健康志愿者由 3 名经验丰富的操作人员分别在 1 周的间隔内进行了两次检查。从第 3、5/6 和 7/8 段获得了 10 次读数。记录了年龄、BMI 和 CB 距离。对观察者间和观察者内研究进行了可靠性分析的 Cronbach α 统计。多元线性回归模型确定了其他参数的显著性。
共记录了 1800 次速度测量值。平均值±标准差:第 3 段,1.31±0.19 m/s;第 5/6 段,1.12±0.22 m/s;第 7/8 段,1.12±0.17 m/s。对于观察者间和观察者内研究,当从第 5/6 和 7/8 段获取时,Cronbach α 统计值均≥0.7(可靠),但从第 3 段获取时则<0.7(不可靠)。BMI 和年龄与 ARFI 速度呈显著(p<0.0001)但相反的相关性(第 5/6 段:BMI r=0.02,年龄 r=-0.02;第 7/8 段:BMI r=-0.01,年龄 r=0.01),当对被认为可靠的段进行分析时。两个评估段的 ARFI 速度与肝 CB 距离之间显示出较弱的负相关性(第 5/6 段,r=-0.08;第 7/8 段,r=-0.06;p<0.001)。
在经过培训的操作人员的情况下,ARFI 是一种可靠且可重复的肝段硬度定量方法,但应避免从第 3 段获取测量值。从肝包膜深处获得的数值允许更可靠的肝硬度定量。