Department of Epidemiology, Crisis Organization and Diagnostics, Central Veterinary Institute, Wageningen University and Research Centre, Lelystad, The Netherlands.
PLoS One. 2012;7(7):e40929. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0040929. Epub 2012 Jul 13.
Estimates of the per-contact probability of transmission between farms of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza virus of H7N7 subtype during the 2003 epidemic in the Netherlands are important for the design of better control and biosecurity strategies. We used standardized data collected during the epidemic and a model to extract data for untraced contacts based on the daily number of infectious farms within a given distance of a susceptible farm. With these data, we used a maximum likelihood estimation approach to estimate the transmission probabilities by the individual contact types, both traced and untraced. The estimated conditional probabilities, conditional on the contact originating from an infectious farm, of virus transmission were: 0.000057 per infectious farm within 1 km per day, 0.000413 per infectious farm between 1 and 3 km per day, 0.0000895 per infectious farm between 3 and 10 km per day, 0.0011 per crisis organisation contact, 0.0414 per feed delivery contact, 0.308 per egg transport contact, 0.133 per other-professional contact and, 0.246 per rendering contact. We validate these outcomes against literature data on virus genetic sequences for outbreak farms. These estimates can be used to inform further studies on the role that improved biosecurity between contacts and/or contact frequency reduction can play in eliminating between-farm spread of the virus during future epidemics. The findings also highlight the need to; 1) understand the routes underlying the infections without traced contacts and, 2) to review whether the contact-tracing protocol is exhaustive in relation to all the farm's day-to-day activities and practices.
在荷兰 2003 年 H7N7 亚型高致病性禽流感疫情期间,农场间高度传染性禽流感病毒的每接触传播概率估计对于设计更好的控制和生物安全策略非常重要。我们使用疫情期间收集的标准化数据和模型,根据给定距离内易感农场内传染性农场的日数量,从无追踪接触中提取数据。利用这些数据,我们使用最大似然估计方法,根据接触是否源自传染性农场,分别估计追踪和无追踪接触类型的传播概率。接触源自传染性农场时,病毒传播的条件概率为:每天每 1 公里内的传染性农场为 0.000057,每天每 1 至 3 公里内的传染性农场为 0.000413,每天每 3 至 10 公里内的传染性农场为 0.0000895,危机组织接触为 0.0011,饲料运送接触为 0.0414,鸡蛋运输接触为 0.308,其他专业接触为 0.133,剖检接触为 0.246。我们将这些结果与疫情农场病毒遗传序列的文献数据进行了验证。这些估计可用于进一步研究在未来疫情中,改善接触者之间的生物安全和/或减少接触频率在消除农场间病毒传播方面的作用。研究结果还强调需要:1)了解无追踪接触的感染途径,2)审查接触追踪协议是否涵盖了农场日常活动和实践的所有方面。