Yeager Valerie A, Menachemi Nir
Department of Health Care Organization and Policy, School of Public Health, University of Alabama at Birmingham, USA.
Adv Health Care Manag. 2011;11:235-61. doi: 10.1108/s1474-8231(2011)0000011013.
Studies suggest text messaging is beneficial to health care; however, no one has synthesized the overall evidence on texting interventions. In response to this need, we conducted a systematic review of the impacts of text messaging in health care.
PubMed database searches and subsequent reference list reviews sought English-language, peer-reviewed studies involving text messaging in health care. Commentaries, conference proceedings, and feasibilities studies were excluded. Data was extracted using an article coding sheet and input into a database for analysis.
Of the 61 papers reviewed, 50 articles (82%) found text messaging had a positive effect on the primary outcome. Average sample sizes in articles reporting positive findings (n=813) were significantly larger than those that did not find a positive impact (n=178) on outcomes (p = 0.032). Articles were categorized into focal groups as follows: 27 articles (44.3%) investigated the impact of texting on disease management, 24 articles (39.3%) focused texting's impact to public health related outcomes, and 10 articles (16.4%) examined texting and its influence on administrative processes. Articles in focal groups differed by the purpose of the study, direction of the communication, and where they were published, but not in likelihood of reporting a positive impact from texting.
Current evidence indicates that text messaging health care interventions are largely beneficial clinically, in public health related uses, and in terms of administrative processes. However, despite the promise of these findings, literature gaps exist, especially in primary care settings, across geographic regions and with vulnerable populations.
研究表明短信对医疗保健有益;然而,没有人综合整理过关于短信干预的总体证据。为满足这一需求,我们对短信在医疗保健中的影响进行了系统综述。
通过检索PubMed数据库及随后查阅参考文献列表,寻找涉及医疗保健中短信应用的英文同行评审研究。评论、会议论文集和可行性研究被排除在外。使用文章编码表提取数据并输入数据库进行分析。
在 reviewed 的61篇论文中,50篇文章(82%)发现短信对主要结局有积极影响。报告有积极结果的文章的平均样本量(n = 813)显著大于未发现对结局有积极影响的文章的平均样本量(n = 178)(p = 0.032)。文章按焦点组分类如下:27篇文章(44.3%)研究了短信对疾病管理的影响,24篇文章(39.3%)关注短信对公共卫生相关结局的影响,10篇文章(16.4%)考察了短信及其对行政流程的影响。焦点组中的文章在研究目的、沟通方向和发表地点上存在差异,但在报告短信产生积极影响的可能性方面没有差异。
目前的证据表明,短信医疗保健干预在临床、公共卫生相关用途以及行政流程方面大多是有益的。然而,尽管有这些研究结果,但仍存在文献空白,尤其是在初级保健环境、不同地理区域以及弱势群体中。